项目面板是一款免费工具,仅向已认证的酒店从业者开放。它通过简化调研流程和沟通环节,让采用新技术变得更轻松。
摘要
我们分析了 37 条经验证的酒店经营者评价,比较了功能集、定价和真实案例研究,以全面解析每个平台的优势。最佳选择取决于您的酒店类型和优先事项:
Shiji Group 在项目沟通与跟进方面表现出色,尤其适合民宿住宿设施(4.9/5),并拥有宾客资料以及平板电脑/自助值机等独家功能。
基于 HTR 上 37 条经验证的酒店经营者评价的并排评分。
| HTScore |
|
|
| 推荐可能性 |
|
|
| 易用性 |
|
|
| 客户支持 |
|
|
| 性价比 |
|
|
| 起始价格 | 联系销售 | 起价 $1,200/月 |
| 经验证的评价 | 0 | 37 |
在分析了 37 条经验证的评价后,Comanche International 用户最看重其 ,而 Shiji Group 用户则强调 项目沟通与跟进, 支持的可用性和响应速度, 部署过程中问题极少。点击任意主题查看评价者的反馈。
|
|
|
|---|---|
| 优点 | |
|
+
项目沟通与跟进
▾
|
|
|
+
支持的可用性和响应速度
▾
|
|
|
+
部署过程中问题极少
▾
|
|
|
+
员工的专业性和乐于助人
▾
|
|
| 缺点 | |
各产品在不同酒店规模、类型和区域的 酒店运营软件(PMS) 供应商中的排名——基于各细分市场中酒店经营者的经验证评价。
按酒店规模
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 小型(10-24 间客房) | — | #59 2 条评价 |
| 中型(25-74 间客房) ▾ | — | #31 17 条评价 |
| 大型(75-199 间客房) ▾ | — | #11 16 条评价 |
| 超大型(200+ 间客房) | — | #18 2 条评价 |
按酒店类型
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 精品酒店 ▾ | — | #32 19 条评价 |
| 豪华酒店 ▾ | — | #26 25 条评价 |
| 品牌/连锁酒店 ▾ | — | #23 20 条评价 |
| 长住酒店 | — | #36 3 条评价 |
按区域
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 北美 | — | #32 4 条评价 |
| 欧洲 ▾ | — | #31 10 条评价 |
| 亚太 ▾ | — | #15 5 条评价 |
| 中东 ▾ | — | #3 15 条评价 |
Choosing between Comanche PMS and Shiji Daylight PMS hinges on your hotel’s specific needs, resources, and growth ambitions. While Comanche claims to serve a broad range of hospitality operations since 1996, it offers no recent reviews or user ratings, raising questions about current functionality and support. Conversely, Shiji Daylight PMS, backed by 32 recent reviews and a high NPS score, demonstrates a strong reputation for ease of use, support, and feature depth. Which platform truly aligns with your hotel's goals?
Both products aim to streamline hotel operations, but their market presence and technological maturity differ significantly. Comanche, with no recent reviews, appears less active or less visible in the current market, especially outside its core regions. Shiji, with a global footprint across 18 countries and extensive third-party integrations, clearly has a modern, cloud-based architecture designed for scalable, multi-property management. Which product aligns with your hotel’s geographic and operational scale?
Are you prioritizing a mature, widely supported PMS with proven scalability, or are you open to exploring a less documented solution? Your choice depends on whether you value current user feedback and comprehensive features, or if you are willing to consider a lesser-known platform with limited recent data. How confident are you in the stability and ongoing support of each option?
If your hotel needs a straightforward, well-established system with a long history of serving hotels in Asia Pacific, Comanche might seem appealing. However, with no recent reviews or visible customer satisfaction data, it’s difficult to confirm if the platform currently meets modern hospitality demands. For hotels seeking a scalable, modern cloud-native PMS with extensive features and proven support, Shiji Daylight PMS is clearly the superior choice. It offers a comprehensive suite of 98 features, including guest profiles, online check-in, and integrated CRS, that support high-volume operations.
Your hotel with a focus on ease of use, quick onboarding, and robust support should lean toward Shiji. The platform’s high ratings in user-friendliness, training, and customer support—averaging 4.63/5, 4.53/5, and an NPS of 8.94/10—demonstrate its reliability in real-world environments. If operational efficiency and guest personalization are critical, Shiji’s extensive feature set makes it a more future-proof investment.
Conversely, if your operation is small, regional, or heavily dependent on legacy systems, Comanche’s lack of recent data makes it less advisable. Without current reviews or clear support metrics, committing to Comanche could pose risks for scalability, ongoing support, and feature updates. Which platform do you see as capable of supporting your hotel’s growth and technological evolution?
Shiji Daylight PMS scores a remarkable 4.63/5 in ease of use, with many reviews highlighting its intuitive interface and straightforward training materials. Users praise how quickly new staff can learn the system and perform daily tasks, thanks to detailed videos and user-friendly design. Support teams are also consistently rated highly, facilitating smoother onboarding and ongoing assistance.
In contrast, Comanche PMS has no recent reviews or user ratings, making it impossible to assess its current usability or onboarding experience. Its long-standing presence suggests familiarity for some users, but without updated feedback, it’s unclear whether it matches modern usability standards. Based on available data, the edge clearly goes to Shiji.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
Shiji Daylight PMS offers a robust 98 features, including guest profiles, multilingual support, online check-in/out, task management, integrated CRS, and more. It also includes advanced modules like digital registration, automated reminders, real-time reporting, and integrated payment solutions. Many features cater to large, multi-property operations, enabling detailed guest data management and operational automation.
Comanche PMS, on the other hand, provides no documented features or recent updates, making it impossible to compare feature depth directly. Its lack of recent reviews suggests it may not have kept pace with technological advancements or modern guest expectations.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
Shiji Group’s support receives a high rating of 4.53/5, with recent reviews praising its responsiveness, professionalism, and helpful training materials. Support staff is frequently described as proactive and able to resolve issues efficiently, which is critical during implementation and daily operations.
There are no recent reviews or ratings for Comanche PMS, leaving its support performance ambiguous. Without evidence of current customer satisfaction, it’s safer to trust Shiji’s well-documented support excellence.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
Shiji PMS integrates with 64 verified partners, including major systems like SiteMinder, Onity, D-Edge, Duetto, and Cendyn. These integrations allow hotels to connect POS, revenue management, booking engines, and other operational tools, supporting complex, multi-system environments.
Comanche PMS has only 12 verified partners, mainly regional or less commonly used integrations like Vertical Booking and RateGain. Its limited integrations could restrict your hotel’s ability to connect with preferred or modern technology solutions.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
While Comanche has no recent reviews or ratings, Shiji Daylight PMS has accumulated 32 recent reviews, with an average NPS score of 8.94/10. Hoteliers across segments, especially luxury and branded hotels, praise its ease of use, support, and feature depth.
The absence of recent feedback for Comanche suggests it’s no longer front-of-mind for modern hoteliers. Based on current data, Shiji is clearly the higher-rated platform.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
Comanche PMS’s pricing details are unavailable, and it does not offer a free tier or trial. Its unclear pricing model makes it difficult to evaluate value or compare with competitors.
Shiji Daylight PMS costs $1,200 per month, with no mention of implementation fees or discounts, aligning with typical cloud-based PMS pricing. Its transparent fee structure offers clarity for budget planning.
Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.
Not ideal if your hotel:
Not ideal if your hotel:
Comanche PMS’s long-standing presence and regional focus make it suitable for smaller or regional operators with familiar workflows, but its lack of recent reviews, features, and support data raise concerns about its current viability. It’s best suited for operations that prioritize a known, simple solution over technological innovation.
Shiji Daylight PMS, with extensive recent reviews, high ratings, and a broad feature set, clearly stands out for hotels aiming to modernize operations, enhance guest experiences, and support growth across regions. Its cloud architecture, integrations, and user-friendly design make it a dependable choice for most hotel types.
If your hotel needs a proven, scalable platform that adapts to modern hospitality demands, Shiji is the clear winner. However, if you’re constrained by regional or legacy system considerations, Comanche might still serve in a limited capacity—though with significant caveats.
酒店运营软件(PMS) 的定价很少是简单明了的。以下是我们从各供应商公开定价数据中了解到的信息。请务必根据您的酒店规模申请定制报价。
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 起始价格 | — | 起价 $1,200/月 |
这些是每个供应商配置的功能,按功能组进行整理——与供应商后台中显示的数据相同。展开任意功能组即可并排比较功能。
| 功能 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
▾
会计与金融
|
|
|
| 直接计费 | ||
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 多币种 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
| 自动夜间审计 | ||
|
▾
营销与电子商务
|
|
|
| 访客通信(短信) | ||
| 原生电子邮件营销 | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 客户关系管理 | ||
| 礼品卡 | ||
| 频道管理员 | ||
| 预订引擎 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
管理和配置
|
|
|
| 集中的用户和角色管理 | ||
| 多种语言 | ||
| 基于云 | ||
| 在前提 | ||
|
▾
用户管理
|
|
|
| 访客通信(短信) | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 集中消息传递 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
前台
|
|
|
| 移动设备笔记和任务(语音转文本) | ||
| 移动应用 | ||
| 自动夜间审计 | ||
| 日历视图 | ||
| 多种语言 | ||
| 任务管理 | ||
| 自动提醒 | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 平板电脑/自助服务终端值机 | ||
| 付款请求 | ||
| 集中消息传递 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
|
▾
群组管理
|
|
|
| 组功能 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
|
▾
宾客体验
|
|
|
| 集成身份证和护照扫描仪 | ||
| 数字注册 | ||
| 访客应用 | ||
| 网上值机 | ||
| 在线结帐 | ||
| 来宾消息 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
| 身份证扫描和注册预填 | ||
| 大堂售货亭 | ||
|
▾
家政
|
|
|
| 管家模块 | ||
| 家政移动应用程序 | ||
| 实时状态更新 | ||
| 自动分配 | ||
| 实时报告 | ||
| 轮班计划 | ||
| 员工信息 | ||
| 在线结帐 | ||
|
▾
付款
|
|
|
| 集成支付终端和读卡器 | ||
| 直接计费 | ||
| 多币种 | ||
| 交付过程 | ||
| 付款请求 | ||
|
▾
预订管理
|
|
|
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 礼品卡 | ||
| 频道管理员 | ||
| 综合 CRS | ||
| 拖放磁带图 | ||
| 费率管理 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
| 基于规则的房间分配 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
收入管理
|
|
|
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 自定义费率 | ||
| 辅助收入跟踪 | ||
| 收益管理模块 | ||
| 基本定价 | ||
|
▾
税务与合规
|
|
|
| 符合 PCI 标准 | ||
| 符合 GDPR | ||
| SOC2 投诉 | ||
| 税务配置 | ||
|
▾
支持与培训
|
|
|
| 在线 24/7 支持 | ||
|
▾
食品与饮料
|
|
|
| EPoS | ||
|
▾
温泉
|
|
|
| 水疗和健康模块 |
我们分析了 4 个经验证的案例研究,比较了酒店在四个关键业务目标上使用每个平台实际取得的成果。
该目标暂无已发布的案例研究。
"All the big players don't offer the level of API connectivity we need, but Shiji does. From the early stages of our design process, we were confident that Shiji could provide us wi..."
该目标暂无已发布的案例研究。
"We reduced check-in time by over 80%, from up to eight minutes to just about one minute with the new system."
酒店经营者喜爱的方面
客户强调,世纪团队沟通清晰,始终让相关方了解进展。这种跟进程度帮助酒店避免实施过程中的混乱,支持更顺利的过渡。
评论指出,世纪支持在需要时随时可用,且客服代表乐于助人且响应迅速。这在设置和初期使用阶段,尤其是遇到时间敏感问题时,给酒店带来了信心。
反馈表明安装本身几乎没有问题,任何小故障都归因于酒店内部管理混乱,而非Shiji。对于正在评估该系统的酒店来说,这意味着实施风险较低,部署更可预测。
独特功能
这取决于您的需求。Comanche PMS 和 Shiji Daylight PMS 共享许多核心 Property Management Systems 功能,但各有独特的能力。Comanche PMS 提供 13 个经验证的集成合作伙伴,而 Shiji Daylight PMS 提供 72 个。在切换之前,请查看上方的功能对比以了解它们的差异。
Comanche PMS:否。Shiji Daylight PMS:否。 两款产品目前均不提供免费版。大多数 Property Management Systems 供应商提供演示或试用——在做出承诺之前,请分别向各供应商申请体验。
HT Score 是一个综合排名,考虑 4 个标准组和十多个变量,帮助酒店经营者客观比较酒店科技产品。Comanche International 的 HT Score 为 0,Shiji Group 的为 75。以下是评分的计算方式。
| 标准组 | 权重 | 衡量内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 客户评分与评价 |
|
用户对该产品的推荐度如何? 评分分数、评价数量、声量份额、评价深度、评价时效性、成功案例 ▾ 权重最高的因素。分析平均满意度评分(推荐可能性、易用性、支持、投资回报率)、相对于同类产品的评价总数、评价时效性(最近 6 个月内至少 20 条评价)以及跨独立酒店客户的声量份额以检测选择偏差。 |
| 合作伙伴生态系统 |
|
技术合作伙伴对该公司的推荐度如何? 合作伙伴推荐、集成数量、集成质量 ▾ 评估合作伙伴推荐作为专家信心投票、经验证集成的数量以及生态系统质量——集成合作伙伴的平均 HT Score。拥有更高质量集成生态系统的产品更有可能提供互联互通的技术栈。 |
| 以客户为中心 |
|
该组织以客户为中心的程度如何? 认证支持、评价一致性、资料完整性 ▾ 评估公司是否获得 HTR 客户支持认证、是否保持持续的评价收集(反馈驱动文化的指标)以及产品资料是否完整,包括功能、截图、定价和特性。 |
| 覆盖范围、持久力与资源 |
|
该公司的覆盖范围和资源有多广泛? 地理覆盖、持久力、公司资源、趋势评分 ▾ 衡量全球覆盖(服务的国家和区域)、经营年限作为稳定性指标、团队规模作为资源指标,以及基于近十二个月买家咨询、评价、合作伙伴推荐和媒体活动的趋势评分。 |
客户评分和评价是 HT Score 算法中最重要的因素。HTR 不接受付费以提高排名。所有评价均经过验证——只有经确认从属关系的酒店行业从业者才能提交评分。 查看完整 HT Score 评估方法 →
根据您酒店的情况量身定制的推荐