项目面板是一款免费工具,仅向已认证的酒店从业者开放。它通过简化调研流程和沟通环节,让采用新技术变得更轻松。
摘要
我们分析了 238 条经验证的酒店经营者评价,比较了功能集、定价和真实案例研究,以全面解析每个平台的优势。最佳选择取决于您的酒店类型和优先事项:
myCloud Hospitality PMS 在易用性以及客户支持方面表现出色,尤其适合度假住宿设施(4.6/5),并拥有移动应用以及平板电脑/自助服务终端值机等独家功能。
Planet 在功能和特点方面表现出色,尤其适合度假租赁住宿设施(4.3/5),并拥有在前提等独家功能。
基于 HTR 上 238 条经验证的酒店经营者评价的并排评分。
| HTScore |
|
|
| 推荐可能性 |
|
|
| 易用性 |
|
|
| 客户支持 |
|
|
| 性价比 |
|
|
| 起始价格 | 起价 $900/月 | 起价 $500/月 |
| 经验证的评价 | 110 | 128 |
在分析了 238 条经验证的评价后,myCloud Hospitality PMS 用户最看重其 客户支持与问题解决, 易用性 / 直观导航, 入职培训与培训,而 Planet 用户则强调 功能和特点, 易于使用, 多物业管理。点击任意主题查看评价者的反馈。
|
|
|
|---|---|
| 优点 | |
|
+
客户支持与问题解决
▾
|
+
功能和特点
▾
|
|
+
易用性 / 直观导航
▾
|
+
易于使用
▾
|
|
+
入职培训与培训
▾
|
+
多物业管理
▾
|
|
+
报告和后台可见性
▾
|
|
| 缺点 | |
|
−
产品开发速度与移动访问差距
▾
|
−
支持问题
▾
|
|
−
渠道管理器 / 预订同步
▾
|
−
定制和灵活性
▾
|
|
−
性能与速度问题
▾
|
−
系统性能和可靠性
▾
|
各产品在不同酒店规模、类型和区域的 酒店运营软件(PMS) 供应商中的排名——基于各细分市场中酒店经营者的经验证评价。
按酒店规模
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 小型(10-24 间客房) ▾ | #13 73 条评价 | #24 38 条评价 |
| 中型(25-74 间客房) ▾ | #19 30 条评价 | #14 62 条评价 |
| 大型(75-199 间客房) ▾ | #24 5 条评价 | #12 15 条评价 |
| 超大型(200+ 间客房) | #31 1 条评价 | #37 1 条评价 |
按酒店类型
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 精品酒店 ▾ | #16 55 条评价 | #20 51 条评价 |
| 豪华酒店 ▾ | #13 52 条评价 | #20 37 条评价 |
| 品牌/连锁酒店 ▾ | #12 37 条评价 | #17 38 条评价 |
| 长住酒店 ▾ | #37 2 条评价 | #19 11 条评价 |
按区域
| 细分市场 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 北美 ▾ | #42 1 条评价 | #30 6 条评价 |
| 欧洲 ▾ | #54 0 条评价 | #10 100 条评价 |
| 亚太 ▾ | #6 102 条评价 | — |
| 中东 | #20 1 条评价 | #14 2 条评价 |
myCloud Hospitality PMS and protel PMS (by Planet) both target hoteliers seeking cloud-based property management solutions, yet they diverge significantly in focus and operational fit. myCloud Hospitality PMS emphasizes automation and streamlined workflows tailored to small and medium-sized hotels and chains, offering built-in features like channel management and a mobile app to reduce manual effort. In contrast, protel PMS brings its strength in versatility and integration with over 1,200 hospitality systems, supporting a broad range of hotel types including individual properties, chains, and resorts, but with a steeper customization curve.
Both systems solve the core problem of consolidating reservations, billing, guest data, and reporting into a single platform accessible remotely. They enable hotel teams to manage daily operations across the guest journey, from booking to checkout, while improving data accuracy and operational visibility. However, myCloud Hospitality PMS leans towards ease of use and automation for smaller portfolios, whereas protel PMS prioritizes extensibility and multi-property scalability despite some reported complexity.
If your property is a small to medium-sized hotel or a boutique resort valuing ease of use and fast onboarding, myCloud Hospitality PMS stands out with a 4.8/5 ease of use rating across 110 reviews and a 90% likelihood to recommend. Its integrated channel manager and mobile guest apps support operations with fewer dependencies on third-party tools, making it ideal for properties needing rapid deployment and minimal training overhead. Data from 55 boutique hotel reviews averaging 4.5/5 and 47 resort reviews at 4.6/5 support this fit.
Conversely, if you run a multi-property chain or require extensive third-party integrations and customization, protel PMS is more suitable. It boasts 196 verified integrations and a long track record with a 4/5 overall rating from 128 reviews, including 20 recent ones maintaining that score. Although its onboarding (3.8/5) and support (4/5) ratings lag behind myCloud, its ability to centralize management across diverse hotel types—supported by case studies from Bergwelt Grindelwald Resort and Hôtel Paris Bastille—makes it better for complex environments. However, caution is warranted if your operation demands high system responsiveness, as reviews cite slow support and occasional bugs.
Data for limited service hotels and multi-property setups is thin for both, but protel’s broader presence (21 countries vs. myCloud’s 8) and larger user base in city center hotels (11% vs. myCloud’s 7%) further reinforce its suitability for varied portfolios.
myCloud Hospitality PMS leads ease of use with a 4.8/5 rating vs. protel’s 4.2/5, supported by 110 and 128 reviews respectively. Users consistently praise myCloud's intuitive interface, noting rapid staff adoption even among front desk personnel with limited prior experience. Reviewers highlight that its straightforward navigation reduces training time and daily friction, enabling teams to focus more on guest interaction. The onboarding rating of 4.5/5 confirms a smooth transition for new properties.
Protel PMS users appreciate its generally intuitive design but report increased complexity after recent updates and a need for more structured training, reflected in its lower onboarding score of 3.8/5. Multiple reviews mention that certain workflows have become less intuitive, complicating staff adoption, especially in multi-property contexts.
Edge: myCloud Hospitality PMS.
myCloud Hospitality PMS offers 15 unique hotel-specific features not found in protel, including a built-in channel manager, integrated EPoS, automated night audit, mobile guest and employee apps, online check-in/out, and centralized messaging. These features reduce manual tasks and enable front desk and housekeeping teams to automate assignments and reminders, which improves operational efficiency and guest satisfaction. For instance, tablet/kiosk check-ins and mobile keys enable contactless guest experiences, important for both safety and convenience.
Protel PMS’s unique features are limited to on-premise deployment and shift planning, catering to hotels requiring local control or complex staff scheduling. Its advantage lies more in extensibility with 44 shared features plus a vast ecosystem of integrations rather than standalone functionality.
Edge: myCloud Hospitality PMS.
myCloud Hospitality PMS outperforms protel PMS in customer support with a composite rating of 4.8/5 versus 4/5 across 110 and 128 reviews. Reviewers frequently mention rapid, knowledgeable, and helpful support that resolves issues promptly, reducing operational downtime. Training is described as detailed and comprehensive, easing adoption for staff.
Protel PMS users report slower support response times, difficulty reaching phone support, and mixed experiences post-acquisition by Planet. Some reviews describe support delays that disrupt daily operations, although competent assistance is acknowledged when available.
Edge: myCloud Hospitality PMS.
Protel PMS has a significantly larger verified integration network with 196 partners compared to myCloud Hospitality PMS’s 28. Both share 16 common integrations including SiteMinder, SnapShot, Revinate, and RateGain, essential for channel management, analytics, and guest engagement. Protel’s unique partners include Innspire, Right Revenue, and HotelRunner, supporting advanced revenue management and distribution needs, critical for larger or branded hotels.
myCloud’s unique integrations, such as ALICE, Ingenico, and Fornova, support operational tasks like payment processing and guest services, fitting smaller properties aiming for an all-in-one platform.
Edge: protel PMS (by Planet).
Hoteliers rate myCloud Hospitality PMS higher overall with a 4.5/5 across 110 reviews compared to protel PMS’s 4/5 from 128 reviews. Although protel has more recent reviews (20 in the last six months vs. myCloud’s 6), myCloud’s last-six-month rating is not separately available due to review volume but shows steady overall satisfaction.
Boutique hotels rate myCloud at 4.5/5 (55 reviews) versus protel’s 3.9/5 (51 reviews). Resorts show an even wider gap: myCloud at 4.6/5 (47 reviews) against protel’s 4.1/5 (20 reviews). Bed & Breakfasts also favor myCloud (4.4/5) over protel (3.7/5). Protels sees higher ratings in luxury hotels (4.1/5) compared to myCloud’s 4.5/5 but with fewer reviews (37 vs. 52). City center hotels rate protel at 4.1/5 and myCloud at 4.4/5.
Edge: myCloud Hospitality PMS.
myCloud Hospitality PMS lists a base price of $900 with no freemium, monthly flat fee, or per-room pricing, and no implementation fee. Pricing transparency is limited beyond the base fee, with no trial available.
Protel PMS has a lower base price of $500, also without freemium or monthly-per-room pricing, and no implementation fee or trial offered.
Neither system publishes detailed tiered pricing or add-on costs publicly, so buyers should contact vendors for full quotes. The lower entry price for protel may appeal to budget-conscious buyers, but total cost will depend on needed modules and integrations.
Not ideal if:
Not ideal if:
The core difference is that myCloud Hospitality PMS focuses on delivering an easy-to-use, automated, cloud-native PMS tailored to small and medium properties, while protel PMS offers a highly versatile, customizable platform with extensive integrations suited for larger, multi-property operations. myCloud’s strength lies in automation features like mobile check-in/out and integrated EPoS that reduce manual work for front desk and housekeeping teams. Protels excels by providing a robust integration ecosystem and flexible deployment options, including on-premise.
Choose myCloud Hospitality PMS if your priority is fast staff adoption and operational efficiency in small to mid-sized boutique, resort, or limited-service hotels. Its 4.8/5 ease of use and 4.8/5 support ratings across 110 reviews demonstrate reliability and user satisfaction. The built-in channel manager and guest apps further streamline workflows and enhance guest experience.
Choose protel PMS if your hotel requires a scalable, customizable system with broad third-party connectivity and multi-currency payment processing. Protels is better suited for chains and resorts with complex needs and IT support to manage configuration and training. Despite mixed reviews on support and onboarding, its integration depth and hybrid deployment (cloud and on-premise) offer operational flexibility for diverse portfolios.
Edge calls throughout this analysis support a verdict favoring myCloud Hospitality PMS for ease of use, customer support, and overall rating, while protel PMS leads in integrations. Your choice should align with your property size, operational complexity, and IT capability.
酒店运营软件(PMS) 的定价很少是简单明了的。以下是我们从各供应商公开定价数据中了解到的信息。请务必根据您的酒店规模申请定制报价。
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|
| 起始价格 | 起价 $900/月 | 起价 $500/月 |
这些是每个供应商配置的功能,按功能组进行整理——与供应商后台中显示的数据相同。展开任意功能组即可并排比较功能。
| 功能 |
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
▾
会计与金融
|
|
|
| 直接计费 | ||
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 多币种 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
| 自动夜间审计 | ||
|
▾
营销与电子商务
|
|
|
| 访客通信(短信) | ||
| 原生电子邮件营销 | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 客户关系管理 | ||
| 礼品卡 | ||
| 频道管理员 | ||
| 预订引擎 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
管理和配置
|
|
|
| 集中的用户和角色管理 | ||
| 多种语言 | ||
| 基于云 | ||
| 在前提 | ||
|
▾
用户管理
|
|
|
| 访客通信(短信) | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 集中消息传递 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
前台
|
|
|
| 移动设备笔记和任务(语音转文本) | ||
| 移动应用 | ||
| 自动夜间审计 | ||
| 日历视图 | ||
| 多种语言 | ||
| 任务管理 | ||
| 自动提醒 | ||
| 客人资料 | ||
| 平板电脑/自助服务终端值机 | ||
| 付款请求 | ||
| 集中消息传递 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
|
▾
群组管理
|
|
|
| 组功能 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
|
▾
宾客体验
|
|
|
| 集成身份证和护照扫描仪 | ||
| 数字注册 | ||
| 访客应用 | ||
| 网上值机 | ||
| 在线结帐 | ||
| 来宾消息 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
| 身份证扫描和注册预填 | ||
| 大堂售货亭 | ||
|
▾
家政
|
|
|
| 管家模块 | ||
| 家政移动应用程序 | ||
| 实时状态更新 | ||
| 自动分配 | ||
| 实时报告 | ||
| 轮班计划 | ||
| 员工信息 | ||
| 在线结帐 | ||
|
▾
付款
|
|
|
| 集成支付终端和读卡器 | ||
| 直接计费 | ||
| 多币种 | ||
| 交付过程 | ||
| 付款请求 | ||
|
▾
预订管理
|
|
|
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 礼品卡 | ||
| 频道管理员 | ||
| 综合 CRS | ||
| 拖放磁带图 | ||
| 费率管理 | ||
| 自动空间优化 | ||
| 基于规则的房间分配 | ||
| 交易电子邮件(预订、作品集等) | ||
|
▾
收入管理
|
|
|
| RevPaR 和 ADR 报告 | ||
| 自定义费率 | ||
| 辅助收入跟踪 | ||
| 收益管理模块 | ||
| 基本定价 | ||
|
▾
税务与合规
|
|
|
| 符合 PCI 标准 | ||
| 符合 GDPR | ||
| SOC2 投诉 | ||
| 税务配置 | ||
|
▾
支持与培训
|
|
|
| 在线 24/7 支持 | ||
|
▾
食品与饮料
|
|
|
| EPoS | ||
|
▾
温泉
|
|
|
| 水疗和健康模块 |
我们分析了 5 个经验证的案例研究,比较了酒店在四个关键业务目标上使用每个平台实际取得的成果。
该目标暂无已发布的案例研究。
"It feels like a partnership, not a product. Our feedback is always heard and acted on. We’re working together for the shared goal of great guest service."
酒店经营者喜爱的方面
支持是评论中最强的积极因素之一,用户表示团队知识丰富、响应迅速、能够快速解决问题。多条评论提到直接协助模块、故障排除和账户支持,这降低了依赖PMS日常运... 支持是评论中最强的积极因素之一,用户表示团队知识丰富、响应迅速、能够快速解决问题。多条评论提到直接协助模块、故障排除和账户支持,这降低了依赖PMS日常运营的酒店的运营中断。
评审者一致认为MyCloud PMS易于学习和操作,简化了培训负担,即使是前台经验有限的员工也能使用。这种易用性被定位为生产力提升,因为团队可以更快、更顺畅地完... 评审者一致认为MyCloud PMS易于学习和操作,简化了培训负担,即使是前台经验有限的员工也能使用。这种易用性被定位为生产力提升,因为团队可以更快、更顺畅地完成日常任务。
该平台因快速入职和帮助酒店上线而受到称赞,这对于需要快速部署的酒店来说非常有价值。与此同时,用户希望培训能超越前台、客房服务和预订,让酒店团队能更好地... 该平台因快速入职和帮助酒店上线而受到称赞,这对于需要快速部署的酒店来说非常有价值。与此同时,用户希望培训能超越前台、客房服务和预订,让酒店团队能更好地使用配置、费率加载和报告。
酒店经营者提出异议的方面
一些用户希望更快地推出新功能和改进,建议产品可以通过更快的开发周期变得更具竞争力。其他用户指出缺乏移动应用或移动友好访问,这限制了需要在大屏幕之外进行... 一些用户希望更快地推出新功能和改进,建议产品可以通过更快的开发周期变得更具竞争力。其他用户指出缺乏移动应用或移动友好访问,这限制了需要在大屏幕之外进行操作的员工的可用性。
一个经常提及的运营优势是预订渠道、渠道管理器与PMS之间的顺畅同步,这有助于减少手动工作并支持更快的预订处理。主要的缺点是偶尔会出现同步失败,尽管评论者... 一个经常提及的运营优势是预订渠道、渠道管理器与PMS之间的顺畅同步,这有助于减少手动工作并支持更快的预订处理。主要的缺点是偶尔会出现同步失败,尽管评论者指出这些问题通常会被支持团队迅速解决。
排名更高的方面
独特功能
酒店经营者喜爱的方面
用户欣赏 Protel 管理单个物业的广泛功能,以及用于报告、房间规划和费率管理的综合工具。然而,许多评论表示失望,因为在处理更复杂的设置或多物业环境时,这些... 用户欣赏 Protel 管理单个物业的广泛功能,以及用于报告、房间规划和费率管理的综合工具。然而,许多评论表示失望,因为在处理更复杂的设置或多物业环境时,这些功能中的许多功能不完整、有缺陷或完全缺失。自定义报告和与其他工具的无缝集成也被认为是有益的。
用户界面普遍受到好评,因为它直观且易于操作。许多用户发现 Protel Air 特别用户友好,并注意到它在管理日常操作方面非常高效。然而,某些更新使得某些功能比以... 用户界面普遍受到好评,因为它直观且易于操作。许多用户发现 Protel Air 特别用户友好,并注意到它在管理日常操作方面非常高效。然而,某些更新使得某些功能比以前更复杂,更不直观。
Protel 在满足多属性环境方面的表现得到了褒贬不一的反馈。虽然一些用户对其组织工具和界面表示赞赏,但许多人发现该系统在多位置设置方面功能有限,令人沮丧,... Protel 在满足多属性环境方面的表现得到了褒贬不一的反馈。虽然一些用户对其组织工具和界面表示赞赏,但许多人发现该系统在多位置设置方面功能有限,令人沮丧,突出了重大错误和功能减少。
酒店经营者提出异议的方面
客户支持一直是人们关注的焦点。评论提到,在被 Planet 收购后,客户支持请求的等待时间过长、电话服务中断以及响应时间过长。用户建议提高客户服务的速度和可靠... 客户支持一直是人们关注的焦点。评论提到,在被 Planet 收购后,客户支持请求的等待时间过长、电话服务中断以及响应时间过长。用户建议提高客户服务的速度和可靠性。
用户通常对 Protel 提供的定制级别感到满意,这使他们能够调整系统以更好地满足他们的特定需求。然而,这种灵活性通常需要付出高昂的成本,而且一些必需的功能只... 用户通常对 Protel 提供的定制级别感到满意,这使他们能够调整系统以更好地满足他们的特定需求。然而,这种灵活性通常需要付出高昂的成本,而且一些必需的功能只有通过付费定制开发才能获得。
排名更高的方面
独特功能
评分差异最大的方面
这取决于您的需求。myCloud Hospitality PMS 和 protel PMS (by Planet) 共享许多核心 Property Management Systems 功能,但各有独特的能力。myCloud Hospitality PMS 提供 28 个经验证的集成合作伙伴,而 protel PMS (by Planet) 提供 196 个。在切换之前,请查看上方的功能对比以了解它们的差异。
小型酒店应优先考虑易用性和快速上手。myCloud Hospitality PMS 在易用性方面领先,评分为 4.8/5 对比 4.2/5。寻找透明定价以及试用或演示选项。在各产品页面上按酒店规模筛选评价,了解与您类似的酒店的反馈。
myCloud Hospitality PMS:否。protel PMS (by Planet):否。 两款产品目前均不提供免费版。大多数 Property Management Systems 供应商提供演示或试用——在做出承诺之前,请分别向各供应商申请体验。
HT Score 是一个综合排名,考虑 4 个标准组和十多个变量,帮助酒店经营者客观比较酒店科技产品。myCloud Hospitality PMS 的 HT Score 为 75,Planet 的为 74。以下是评分的计算方式。
| 标准组 | 权重 | 衡量内容 |
|---|---|---|
| 客户评分与评价 |
|
用户对该产品的推荐度如何? 评分分数、评价数量、声量份额、评价深度、评价时效性、成功案例 ▾ 权重最高的因素。分析平均满意度评分(推荐可能性、易用性、支持、投资回报率)、相对于同类产品的评价总数、评价时效性(最近 6 个月内至少 20 条评价)以及跨独立酒店客户的声量份额以检测选择偏差。 |
| 合作伙伴生态系统 |
|
技术合作伙伴对该公司的推荐度如何? 合作伙伴推荐、集成数量、集成质量 ▾ 评估合作伙伴推荐作为专家信心投票、经验证集成的数量以及生态系统质量——集成合作伙伴的平均 HT Score。拥有更高质量集成生态系统的产品更有可能提供互联互通的技术栈。 |
| 以客户为中心 |
|
该组织以客户为中心的程度如何? 认证支持、评价一致性、资料完整性 ▾ 评估公司是否获得 HTR 客户支持认证、是否保持持续的评价收集(反馈驱动文化的指标)以及产品资料是否完整,包括功能、截图、定价和特性。 |
| 覆盖范围、持久力与资源 |
|
该公司的覆盖范围和资源有多广泛? 地理覆盖、持久力、公司资源、趋势评分 ▾ 衡量全球覆盖(服务的国家和区域)、经营年限作为稳定性指标、团队规模作为资源指标,以及基于近十二个月买家咨询、评价、合作伙伴推荐和媒体活动的趋势评分。 |
客户评分和评价是 HT Score 算法中最重要的因素。HTR 不接受付费以提高排名。所有评价均经过验证——只有经确认从属关系的酒店行业从业者才能提交评分。 查看完整 HT Score 评估方法 →
根据您酒店的情况量身定制的推荐