Amenitiz vs. NewBook All-in-1 HMS:
あなたに最適なのはどちら？

The Decision

Choosing between Amenitiz by Amenitiz and NewBook All-in-1 HMS hinges on your specific operational needs and priorities. Both platforms aim to streamline hotel management but diverge significantly in their features, user experience, and market presence. With Amenitiz’s recent review count outpacing NewBook’s, it signals a more established user base and ongoing updates, but how do they compare on core hotel management functions?

If your hotel is seeking a comprehensive, customizable platform with built-in channel management, Amenitiz offers an all-in-one solution. Conversely, if ease of use paired with extensive integrations is a priority, NewBook’s superior recent ratings and support may align better with your goals. So, which platform truly fits your hotel’s unique requirements?

Is Amenitiz or NewBook Better for Hotels?

Both Amenitiz and NewBook aim to simplify property management, but they approach this goal differently. Amenitiz consolidates functions into a single interface, offering over 54 features including channel management, booking engine, and guest CRM, all geared toward independent hoteliers wanting control. Meanwhile, NewBook emphasizes ease of use, with a highly-rated support team and a focus on property operations, especially in the RV parks and motels segment.

Amenitiz’s strengths lie in its extensive feature set, including customizable websites and advanced revenue tools, but it has faced criticism for slower support responses and some performance issues. NewBook’s recent reviews highlight its user-friendly interface, seamless onboarding, and dedicated support, though it lacks the same feature depth. How critical are advanced features versus straightforward usability for your team?

Amenitiz vs NewBook: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your hotel needs a feature-rich management system to handle everything from website development to guest CRM and detailed reporting, Amenitiz is the clear choice. Its 54 features, including integrated CRS, payment processing, and group booking tools, are ideal for hotels looking to centralize operations and boost direct bookings.

On the other hand, if your team values simplicity, quick onboarding, and excellent support—especially for properties like RV parks or smaller motels—NewBook offers a more intuitive experience. Its recent reviews emphasize the ease of learning and responsiveness, making it preferable for operators who prioritize support and fast implementation over extensive features.

Is Amenitiz or NewBook Easier to Use?

Amenitiz scores a respectable 4.09/5 for ease of use, with users appreciating its comprehensive yet navigable interface. However, some reviews mention performance issues and a steeper learning curve due to its extensive feature set. The onboarding process appears average, with some users citing room for improvement in training materials.

NewBook outperforms with a 4.67/5 rating, with reviews lauding its intuitive design and smooth onboarding process. Support staff responsiveness and helpful tutorials ease the learning curve, especially for smaller teams or staff unfamiliar with PMS software. When ease of use is your priority, Edge: NewBook.

Which Has Better Features: Amenitiz or NewBook?

Amenitiz's platform includes 54 features, such as a channel manager, integrated CRS, booking engine, guest profiles, and advanced pricing tools, which are absent in NewBook. Notably, Amenitiz offers a property management system, multi-lingual support, online check-in, and digital registration.

NewBook, despite lacking the breadth of features, excels in its core operational tools like central reservation management, online booking, and support for various property types. Its strength lies in simplicity and tailored support rather than feature depth. Edge: Amenitiz, for its extensive, specialized features.

Which Has Better Customer Support: Amenitiz or NewBook?

Customer support ratings favor NewBook, boasting a perfect 5/5 from reviews, with hoteliers praising its responsiveness and dedicated assistance. One review states, “The support desk is so dedicated and creative, helping maximize platform use,” illustrating its superior support quality.

Amenitiz’s support rating sits at 3.99/5, with reviews citing delays and gaps in responsiveness, especially during weekends. Users appreciate its features but often express frustration over support availability. Edge: NewBook.

Which Has More Integrations: Amenitiz or NewBook?

Amenitiz integrates with 5 verified partners, including Lightspeed and CheKin, which cover basic POS and check-in needs. However, NewBook offers 16 verified integrations, including SiteMinder, TripAdvisor, and PriceLabs, providing broader connectivity for property management, distribution, and revenue optimization.

For properties needing extensive third-party integrations, NewBook’s ecosystem is more advantageous. Edge: NewBook.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: Amenitiz or NewBook?

Amenitiz has a higher overall review count (38) but a low overall rating of 0.5/5, severely impacted by negative feedback. Many reviews highlight legal concerns, poor support, and limited functionality that diminish user satisfaction.

NewBook, with only 3 reviews but a perfect 5/5 rating, is rated highly for ease of use, support, and functionality by its users. Its recent reviews reinforce trust, especially among small to medium properties. When considering recent, positive feedback, Edge: NewBook.

How Much Do Amenitiz and NewBook Cost?

Amenitiz’s pricing starts at $200 per month with no free trial, offering an all-in-one package. Pricing details for NewBook are not publicly specified, but it does not appear to have a fixed monthly fee, emphasizing customized billing based on property size and needs.

Your choice may depend on your budget and willingness to invest in a comprehensive platform versus a flexible, support-driven solution with unclear costs.

What Type of Hotel Should Use Amenitiz?

• Hotels seeking extensive automation and customization, including website development, guest CRM, and detailed revenue management.
• Properties aiming to increase direct bookings with customizable booking engines.
• Teams that can dedicate time to learning a feature-rich system.
• Not ideal if your hotel prefers a simple, straightforward setup or has limited technical support capacity.

What Type of Hotel Should Use NewBook?

• Small to medium properties, like motels, RV parks, and cabins, prioritizing ease of use and rapid onboarding.
• Teams that value dedicated customer support and quick problem resolution.
• Properties that want a cloud-based system with integrated online booking and payment.
• Not ideal if you require advanced revenue management tools or extensive integrations beyond core property functions.

The Bottom Line for Hotels

Amenitiz is a comprehensive management platform designed for hotels wanting control and advanced features, especially those focused on boosting direct bookings and revenue. Its extensive tools make it suitable for properties with dedicated management teams willing to navigate its complexity.

NewBook excels in simplicity, support, and ease of onboarding, making it a strong choice for smaller, less tech-savvy properties or those prioritizing support and quick setup. Its limited features are offset by its strong user support and intuitive interface.

If your hotel needs a feature-packed, customizable platform and your team is prepared to handle a steeper learning curve, Amenitiz is the better pick. For streamlined operations with a focus on support and ease of use, NewBook should be your choice.

In conclusion, for hotels with more complex management needs and a focus on revenue, Amenitiz offers unmatched feature depth. But if your priority is user-friendly software that’s easy to implement and backed by excellent support, NewBook delivers a superior experience.