protel PMS (by Planet) vs. Shiji Daylight PMS:
あなたに最適なのはどちら？

The Decision

Choosing between protel PMS by Planet and Shiji Daylight PMS hinges on your hotel's size, complexity, and strategic priorities. Both aim to streamline operations, but they approach this goal differently, with distinct strengths and weaknesses. Your decision should consider your current needs, future plans, and the specific features that matter most to your team.

Protel PMS has a longer history, extensive integrations, and a reputation for reliability, especially for single-property and mid-sized hotels. Meanwhile, Shiji Daylight PMS, with its modern interface and scalability, is often favored by larger hotel groups seeking robust automation and centralized guest data. But which product truly fits your hotel’s unique profile?

Is protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS Better for Hotels?

Protel PMS and Shiji Daylight both solve core hotel management problems: guest reservations, check-in/out, billing, and reporting. However, they diverge significantly in their approach and maturity.

Protel is a seasoned platform with over three decades of development, known for its deep integration ecosystem and customizable features—great for hotels needing tailored operations. Shiji, on the other hand, emphasizes ease of use and automation, with a sleek cloud-native design that supports fast deployment and property expansion.

The key question is whether your hotel needs a flexible, established platform that can handle complex environments or a modern, scalable system designed for growth and efficiency. Does your hotel prioritize extensive back-end customization or streamlined, user-friendly interfaces?

Protel PMS vs Shiji Daylight PMS: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your hotel operates a single property or a small chain that values proven reliability and vast integrations, go with protel PMS. Its rich feature set—including booking engine, guest CRM, and a large partner network—supports complex operations and provides high customization.

Conversely, if your hotel group requires a scalable solution with quick onboarding, automated workflows, and centralized guest profiles, Shiji Daylight PMS is the better pick. It excels in multi-property environments, offering real-time data and a modern interface that reduces training time and increases operational consistency.

Your choice should align with your hotel’s size and growth ambitions: for established, multi-location hotels seeking flexibility, protel is ideal, while for expanding groups focused on automation and guest personalization, Shiji fits better.

Is protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS Easier to Use?

Protel PMS boasts a user satisfaction score of 4.12/5, with many users praising its intuitive layout and fast access to functions. However, some reviews mention that complex configurations and integrations can slow down staff onboarding, especially for larger, multi-property setups.

Shiji Daylight PMS scores slightly higher at 4.63/5, with reviewers highlighting its modern, clean interface and straightforward navigation. Its consistent positive feedback about ease of training—supported by comprehensive materials—makes onboarding smoother for new staff.

Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.

Which Has Better Features: protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS?

Protel offers 46 core features, including booking engine, guest profiles, and mobile notes, with seven unique modules such as revenue management and on-premise options. Its focus on flexible integration and detailed reporting appeals to hotels needing tailored operational tools.

Shiji provides 59 features, from integrated CRS and automation tools to digital registration, guest messaging, and advanced housekeeping modules. Its extensive feature library emphasizes automation, guest personalization, and multi-channel communication.

While Shiji has more features and unique modules, protel's strength lies in its deep integration ecosystem and customizable environment. For a hotel needing rich automation and guest engagement, shiji has the edge.

Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.

Which Has Better Customer Support: protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS?

Protel’s support scores a 3.95/5, with many reviews citing slow response times and occasional unavailability during critical moments. Users appreciate the helpfulness when support is available but note that support delays can disrupt daily operations.

Shiji outperforms with a 4.53/5 rating, with reviews praising its 24/7 support, quick responses, and proactive onboarding. Hotels like Ruby Hotels emphasize the support team’s professionalism and technical expertise.

Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.

Which Has More Integrations: protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS?

Protel boasts over 195 verified partners, including integrations with Innspire, Right Revenue, and RevControl, supporting extensive customization and tailored workflows. Its large ecosystem facilitates connecting with various revenue, CRM, and channel management tools.

Shiji has 64 verified partners, sharing 38 with protel, including Bookboost, Lighthouse, and FLYR Hospitality. Its focus on automation and centralized systems is supported by integrations with CRS, payment terminals, and guest apps.

Protel’s broader ecosystem gives it a slight lead, especially for hotels requiring complex, multi-system setups.

Edge: protel PMS.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: protel PMS or Shiji Daylight PMS?

Protel’s overall ratings stand at 4.11/5 based on 105 reviews, with independent hotels rating it slightly higher (4.5/5). Many smaller properties appreciate its reliability and customizable features, despite some support frustrations.

Shiji scores 74.99/100, with fewer reviews but higher recent favorability, especially among larger hotels and chains. Hotels emphasize its ease of use, automation, and support.

Given the more extensive and recent reviews, protel's rating is more representative of ongoing performance. Still, Shiji’s recent momentum indicates strong approval among larger hotel groups.

Edge: Shiji Daylight PMS.

How Much Do protel PMS and Shiji Daylight PMS Cost?

Protel’s pricing starts at $500/month, with no free tier or trial, reflecting its premium, feature-rich environment. Shiji’s base price is $1,200/month, also without a trial, aligning with its enterprise focus.

Both are subscription-based, with no implementation fees listed. Your selection may hinge on your budget and the value you perceive from their feature sets and support.

What Type of Hotel Should Use protel PMS?

• Hotels that operate a single property or a small chain, especially those needing deep integration with revenue management, booking engine, and guest CRM.
• Teams seeking a customizable, proven platform with extensive third-party integrations.
• Hotels that require either cloud or on-premise solutions, with flexibility for future upgrades.

Not ideal if your hotel is a large, multi-property group with complex automation needs, as support and performance issues can arise in larger setups.

What Type of Hotel Should Use Shiji Daylight PMS?

• Hotel groups with multiple properties that need centralized guest profiles, automation, and consistent operations.
• Hotels prioritizing fast deployment, intuitive interfaces, and automation tools to reduce training and operational costs.
• Teams that want a scalable platform with integrated CRS, digital registration, and extensive guest messaging.

Not ideal if your hotel is small or prefers highly customizable back-end systems without a focus on rapid automation or if you have strict local compliance needs that require extensive regional adaptations.

The Bottom Line for Hotels

Protel PMS by Planet and Shiji Daylight PMS are both capable solutions, but their target audiences differ markedly. Protel’s extensive integrations, customization capabilities, and reliability make it a solid choice for established, mid-sized hotels seeking a flexible platform with proven stability.

Shiji’s modern interface, automation features, and high user ratings make it ideal for larger hotel groups aiming for operational efficiency and guest personalization. It also supports rapid onboarding and scalability, which are critical for growing portfolios.

For hotels prioritizing reliability, extensive integrations, and proven stability, protel is the safer fallback. But if your hotel needs a scalable, intuitive system with automation and excellent support, Shiji offers compelling advantages. Given the recent reviews and higher overall rating, Shiji Daylight PMS is the stronger pick for most hotels today.