NewBook All-in-1 HMS vs. RoomRaccoon HMS:
あなたに最適なのはどちら？

The Decision

Choosing the right hotel management system can dramatically impact your daily operations, revenue, and guest experience. Both NewBook All-in-1 HMS and RoomRaccoon HMS aim to simplify management, but their core strengths differ. Your decision hinges on whether you prioritize recent reviews and extensive features or a more streamlined, globally accessible platform.

NewBook offers a comprehensive all-in-one solution with a focus on simplicity for motels and RV parks, whereas RoomRaccoon provides a highly rated, feature-rich platform especially suited for small hotels and independent operators. Which fits your property’s unique needs better?

Is NewBook or RoomRaccoon Better for Hotels?

Both products aim to streamline hotel operations from a single platform but diverge significantly in their market focus and review data. NewBook, with just 3 reviews, is largely less reviewed recently, making its data less reliable for current decision-making. Conversely, RoomRaccoon boasts 484 reviews, with 8 in the last six months, providing far more recent insights into its performance.

RoomRaccoon’s 4.95/5 overall rating reflects consistent positive feedback, especially from small hotel operators, while NewBook’s zero-star rating signals a lack of recent user validation. Are you comfortable relying on limited or outdated information, or do you prefer a platform with ongoing, current user feedback?

RoomRaccoon vs NewBook: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your property is a small hotel, boutique, or B&B seeking an intuitive, all-in-one platform with proven recent reviews, RoomRaccoon is the better choice. Its 4.95/5 rating from hundreds of reviews shows ongoing satisfaction among similar properties.

On the other hand, if your hotel operates primarily as a motel or RV park and requires a straightforward system without extensive features, NewBook’s fewer reviews and niche focus might suffice. But given the limited recent feedback, RoomRaccoon’s current outperformance makes it the safer bet for most hoteliers looking for proven, scalable solutions.

Is NewBook or RoomRaccoon Easier to Use?

RoomRaccoon scores a near-perfect 4.87/5 on ease of use based on user reviews emphasizing its intuitive, straightforward interface and smooth onboarding. Many users highlight how quickly staff can learn the system, with minimal training needed, and praise its customer support for ongoing assistance.

NewBook’s ease of use, rated at 4.67/5, is described as "amazing" by its very few reviewers, but the limited feedback and absence of recent reviews make this less conclusive. Considering current data, edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Has Better Features: NewBook or RoomRaccoon?

RoomRaccoon offers 57 distinct features, including automated upselling, guest communication modules, revenue management, and extensive integrations. Its feature set supports dynamic pricing, automated housekeeping, and multi-channel distribution, making it suitable for ambitious hotels seeking growth.

NewBook’s feature count is zero, indicating a more basic approach aligned with its smaller, niche market. Given the depth and recent positive feedback on advanced features, edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Has Better Customer Support: NewBook or RoomRaccoon?

NewBook’s support receives a perfect 5/5 rating, with reviews praising their patience, quick responses, and solution-oriented approach. Users describe the support team as "dedicated," „respectful,” and instrumental in maximizing platform benefits.

RoomRaccoon’s support scores 4.74/5, with some users noting occasional delays or inconsistency, though many praise their responsiveness and continuous development. Still, the clear, recent support excellence of NewBook is less supported by current feedback. Edge: NewBook.

Which Has More Integrations: NewBook or RoomRaccoon?

RoomRaccoon’s platform connects with 88 verified partners, including major OTAs, payment providers, and revenue tools, with 8 shared integrations with NewBook. Its extensive marketplace supports a wide array of third-party systems, enhancing operational flexibility.

NewBook’s 16 verified integrations are fewer, focusing on key partners like SiteMinder and Revinate. For broader connectivity, RoomRaccoon clearly leads. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: NewBook or RoomRaccoon?

RoomRaccoon’s user ratings are significantly higher, with a 4.95/5 overall and recent reviews citing increased RevPAR, efficiency, and direct bookings. The platform’s reputation among small hotels and boutique properties is notably strong.

NewBook’s zero rating coupled with only three reviews, none recent, offer no reliable data for comparison. Based on current user feedback, RoomRaccoon’s ratings are far more indicative of satisfaction. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

How Much Do NewBook and RoomRaccoon Cost?

NewBook’s pricing details are unavailable, indicating a possibly custom or enterprise pricing model, often typical for larger systems. RoomRaccoon charges a flat $1,000 monthly fee, with no implementation or setup costs mentioned.

While direct cost comparison is challenging, RoomRaccoon’s transparent pricing and clear value propositions make budgeting easier for small to medium properties. The absence of publicly available NewBook pricing makes it harder to assess value but suggests it may be tailored for larger operations.

What Type of Hotel Should Use NewBook?

• Hotels that operate primarily as motels or RV parks seeking a straightforward, cloud-based system.
• Teams that want an easy-to-implement platform with high support quality.
• Properties that value simplicity over extensive features.
• Small operators looking for a management solution that’s easy to learn and maintain.

Not ideal if:

• Your hotel plans to scale rapidly and needs advanced automation.
• You require deep customization or extensive integrations.
• Your property operates across multiple regions with complex revenue management.

What Type of Hotel Should Use RoomRaccoon?

• Small hotels, B&Bs, and boutique properties aiming for an all-in-one management system.
• Hotels focused on increasing direct bookings, upselling, and ancillary revenue.
• Properties seeking a platform with over 300 integrations and AI-powered tools.
• Teams wanting a user-friendly interface that minimizes training time.

Not ideal if:

• You prefer a basic, low-cost system with minimal features.
• Your property has complex global operations needing extensive customization.
• You are uncomfortable with a platform that requires setup time and ongoing management.

RoomRaccoon vs NewBook: The Bottom Line for Hotels

RoomRaccoon stands out with a superior review base, recent validation, and a broad feature set tailored for small hotels. Its high user satisfaction and extensive integrations support growth and operational efficiency.

NewBook offers a simple, highly supported platform ideal for motels and RV parks, especially if you prioritize dedicated customer service. However, limited recent reviews and features suggest it may be less adaptable as your property scales.

If your hotel emphasizes innovation, automation, and growth, RoomRaccoon is the clear choice. For simpler, support-focused needs, NewBook could suffice, but current data favors RoomRaccoon as the more reliable, validated solution.