The project dashboard is a free tool that is only available to verified hoteliers to make adopting new technology easier by streamlining their research and simplifying their communication workflow.
TLDR
Analisamos 300 avaliacoes verificadas de hoteleiros, comparamos funcionalidades, precos e estudos de caso reais para detalhar onde cada plataforma se destaca. A escolha certa depende do tipo e das prioridades da sua propriedade:
etihad se destaca .
The Guestbook se destaca em ease of use and customer support — especialmente para propriedades independent (5.0/5) , com funcionalidades exclusivas como Redemption Catalog and Multi-Currency Support.
Avaliacoes lado a lado baseadas em 300 avaliacoes verificadas de hoteleiros no HTR.
| HTScore |
|
|
| Probabilidade de Recomendar |
|
|
| Facilidade de Uso |
|
|
| Suporte ao Cliente |
|
|
| Custo-Beneficio |
|
|
| Preco Inicial | Contact sales | From $200/mo |
| Avaliacoes Verificadas | 0 | 300 |
Apos analisar 300 avaliacoes verificadas, os usuarios do etihad mais valorizam , enquanto os usuarios do The Guestbook destacam guest loyalty promotion, easy implementation, direct bookings increase. Clique em qualquer tema para ver o que os avaliadores dizem.
| etihad |
|
|---|---|
| Pros | |
|
+
Guest Loyalty Promotion
▾
|
|
|
+
Easy Implementation
▾
|
|
|
+
Direct Bookings Increase
▾
|
|
|
+
Redenção e Recompensas
▾
|
|
| Contras | |
|
−
Atrito Operacional
▾
|
|
|
−
Suporte de Marketing
▾
|
|
|
−
Crítica à Expansão da Parceria
▾
|
|
Como cada produto se classifica entre os fornecedores de Programas de Fidelidade para Independentes para diferentes tamanhos, tipos e regioes de propriedades — com base em avaliacoes verificadas de hoteleiros em cada segmento.
Por Tamanho do Hotel
| Segmento | etihad |
|
|---|---|---|
| Pequeno (10-24 quartos) ▾ | — | #1 36 avaliacoes |
| Medio (25-74 quartos) ▾ | — | #1 147 avaliacoes |
| Grande (75-199 quartos) ▾ | — | #1 68 avaliacoes |
| Extra Grande (200+ quartos) ▾ | — | #1 38 avaliacoes |
Por Tipo de Propriedade
| Segmento | etihad |
|
|---|---|---|
| Boutique ▾ | — | #1 163 avaliacoes |
| Luxo ▾ | — | #1 128 avaliacoes |
| Rede / Cadeia ▾ | — | #1 69 avaliacoes |
| Estadia Prolongada ▾ | — | #1 23 avaliacoes |
Por Regiao
| Segmento | etihad |
|
|---|---|---|
| America do Norte ▾ | — | #1 217 avaliacoes |
| Europa ▾ | — | #2 32 avaliacoes |
| Asia-Pacifico ▾ | — | #1 16 avaliacoes |
| Oriente Medio ▾ | — | #2 6 avaliacoes |
You’re evaluating two loyalty program platforms: etihad by etihad and The Guestbook by The Guestbook, both designed to boost direct bookings and guest loyalty for independent hotels. While etihad’s offering appears to lack reviews, features, and recent data, The Guestbook boasts a highly rated, well-established platform with extensive real-world success stories. Which solution will truly meet your hotel’s needs?
Both platforms aim to enhance guest loyalty and increase direct bookings, but they diverge sharply in credibility and depth of features. etihad’s zero reviews and nonexistent recent data make it difficult to assess its effectiveness or user satisfaction, whereas The Guestbook has over 267 recent reviews with a near-perfect rating of 4.95/5. Its proven results and active presence in multiple regions suggest it’s the more reliable choice.
Do you want a platform that’s proven in the field or one whose capabilities and support are still unverified? The Guestbook’s extensive customer feedback and case studies demonstrate its ability to deliver measurable results. Given this disparity, it’s clear that The Guestbook offers more confidence for your hotel’s loyalty strategy.
If your priority is a highly rated, proven loyalty platform with a broad feature set and robust support, go with The Guestbook. Its focus on independent hotels, customizable rewards, and extensive integrations make it ideal for properties seeking direct booking growth and guest retention.
If you’re considering etihad primarily due to a potential brand affiliation or future promises that are unverified, it’s a risky bet. With no reviews or recent activity, etihad cannot currently match The Guestbook’s track record of success and customer satisfaction. For immediate results and confidence, The Guestbook is the clear choice.
The Guestbook’s user interface earns a stellar 4.81/5 rating, with reviews highlighting its simplicity and seamless experience for both guests and hotel staff. Its onboarding process is rated 4.78/5, with many users praising its straightforward setup and intuitive management dashboard, which allows granular data analysis and easy customization.
In contrast, etihad’s ratings are nonexistent, and there are no reviews to gauge its usability or onboarding ease. The lack of data suggests it’s either not widely adopted or still in development. Edge: The Guestbook.
The Guestbook offers 13 distinct features, including a redemption catalog, multi-currency support, partner management, open API, points bank, loyalty rules engine, rewards network, cash back rewards, future stay rewards, and charitable donation options. These comprehensive tools enable tailored, attractive loyalty programs that motivate repeat stays and enhance guest satisfaction.
etihad, on the other hand, provides no publicly available features or details to compare. Without any feature set or differentiation, etihad cannot compete with The Guestbook’s extensive capabilities. Edge: The Guestbook.
The Guestbook’s customer support is rated 4.9/5, with reviews praising its responsiveness, proactive engagement, and ongoing partnership. Review quotes emphasize how support teams help hotels maximize program benefits, streamline operations, and adapt to changing needs.
There are no reviews or ratings for etihad support, making it impossible to determine its responsiveness or quality. Given the importance of reliable support in loyalty programs, this absence favors The Guestbook. Edge: The Guestbook.
The Guestbook boasts 36 verified integrations with popular hotel management and booking systems, including Digital Hotelier, WebRezPro, ReservHOTEL, and others. These integrations facilitate smooth setup, data synchronization, and operational efficiency.
etihad has zero verified integrations, which limits its flexibility and ease of implementation. Hotels seeking a platform that works well with existing systems will find The Guestbook’s extensive partner network more advantageous. Edge: The Guestbook.
With 267 recent reviews and a near-perfect rating of 4.95/5, The Guestbook is overwhelmingly preferred by hoteliers across all segments, including independent, boutique, and mid-sized properties. Review highlights focus on its ease of use, tangible revenue improvements, and seamless operations.
In contrast, etihad has no reviews or ratings, making it impossible to assess user satisfaction. Given the current data, The Guestbook’s user base clearly favors its platform. Edge: The Guestbook.
etihad’s pricing details are unavailable, with no indication of fees, monthly charges, or implementation costs. This opacity makes it difficult to compare value or budget accordingly.
The Guestbook charges a fixed $200 base fee, with no monthly or per-room charges, and no mention of implementation fees. Its transparent pricing model simplifies budgeting and planning. Based on available data, The Guestbook offers a more predictable and accessible investment.
Hotels that might consider etihad are currently unknown, due to the lack of publicly available information, reviews, or feature details. If your hotel is seeking a trusted, well-supported loyalty platform with proven results, etihad does not meet that criterion.
Not ideal if you prefer a free or very low-cost solution (since The Guestbook’s base fee is $200), or if your hotel’s target segment is not well represented (e.g., large resorts or chain hotels).
The core difference between these two options is credibility. The Guestbook is an established, highly-rated platform with extensive features, proven results, and positive reviews from a broad range of hotels worldwide. etihad, lacking reviews and recent data, remains unverified and unsuitable for hotels seeking immediate, measurable benefits.
Choose The Guestbook if your goal is a reliable, feature-rich solution with a demonstrated ability to increase direct bookings and guest loyalty. Its widespread integrations, dedicated support, and proven ROI make it the safer, smarter investment.
If, however, your hotel is willing to explore untested options or is waiting for more transparency, etihad might be worth monitoring — but it’s not currently positioned as a viable choice for hotels aiming for growth and stability.
In conclusion, The Guestbook’s extensive recent reviews, proven case studies, and comprehensive feature set give your hotel a clear path forward. Its high satisfaction ratings and active regional presence further establish it as the better choice for independent hotels committed to loyalty and direct booking growth.
Os precos de Programas de Fidelidade para Independentes raramente sao simples. Aqui esta o que sabemos com base nos dados publicos de precos de cada fornecedor. Sempre solicite uma cotacao personalizada para o tamanho da sua propriedade.
| etihad |
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | — | From $200/mo |
De acordo com o banco de dados de produtos do HTR, etihad e The Guestbook compartilham 0 funcionalidades. Aqui estao as principais diferencas — funcionalidades que um tem e o outro nao.
| Funcionalidade | etihad |
|
|---|---|---|
| API aberta | ||
| Banco de pontos | ||
| Catálogo de Resgate | ||
| Câmbio monetário | ||
| Gerenciamento de parceiros | ||
| Suporte a várias moedas |
Mostrando as principais diferencas. 1 funcionalidades adicionais diferem entre esses produtos.
Analisamos 8 estudos de caso verificados para comparar o que os hoteis realmente alcancam com cada plataforma em quatro objetivos de negocio principais.
Nenhum estudo de caso publicado para este objetivo ainda.
"The Guestbook has increased direct bookings for us over the years. They have always been flexible with custom needs to assist our property and our initiatives. The best part is y..."
Nenhum estudo de caso publicado para este objetivo ainda.
"One of the greatest tools we incorporated in several years!"
O que os hoteleiros adoram
The Guestbook's rewards program effectively fosters guest loyalty, resulting in more repeat stays. Users appreciate the simple and transparent rewards... The Guestbook's rewards program effectively fosters guest loyalty, resulting in more repeat stays. Users appreciate the simple and transparent rewards, which are attractive to both guests and hoteliers and help in promoting brand loyalty.
Reviews frequently highlight the effortless integration and straightforward setup of The Guestbook, which requires minimal effort from hotel staff. Th... Reviews frequently highlight the effortless integration and straightforward setup of The Guestbook, which requires minimal effort from hotel staff. This ease of use extends to guests, making the program attractive and easy to adopt for all parties involved.
Users appreciate how The Guestbook significantly increases direct bookings, which helps hotels reduce dependency on OTAs and avoid high commission fee... Users appreciate how The Guestbook significantly increases direct bookings, which helps hotels reduce dependency on OTAs and avoid high commission fees. Reviews consistently mention measurable revenue growth and enhanced guest relationships due to the increased direct bookings.
Onde os hoteleiros criticam
Alguns usuários mencionam atritos operacionais, como problemas ocasionais com o rastreamento de resgates e o tempo de reconciliação. Algumas avaliaçõe... Alguns usuários mencionam atritos operacionais, como problemas ocasionais com o rastreamento de resgates e o tempo de reconciliação. Algumas avaliações sugerem melhorias na automação e extensões de tempo para reconciliação de recompensas.
Algumas avaliações sugerem a necessidade de mais suporte de marketing do The Guestbook, já que os hotéis desejam capitalizar totalmente os benefícios... Algumas avaliações sugerem a necessidade de mais suporte de marketing do The Guestbook, já que os hotéis desejam capitalizar totalmente os benefícios do programa de fidelidade. Oportunidades para iniciativas de marketing adicionais e parcerias com empresas de cartão de crédito são mencionadas.
Capacidades exclusivas
Onde as avaliacoes mais divergem
Depende dos seus requisitos. etihad e The Guestbook compartilham muitas funcionalidades principais de Loyalty Programs for Independents, mas cada um tem capacidades unicas. etihad oferece 0 parceiros de integracao verificados, enquanto The Guestbook oferece 36. Revise a comparacao de funcionalidades acima para ver onde eles diferem antes de migrar.
Hoteis pequenos devem priorizar facilidade de uso e onboarding rapido. The Guestbook lidera em facilidade de uso com 4.8/5 vs 0.0/5. Procure precos transparentes e opcao de teste ou demonstracao. Filtre as avaliacoes na pagina de cada produto por tamanho de propriedade para ouvir hoteis como o seu.
etihad: Nao. The Guestbook: Nao. Nenhum dos produtos oferece um plano gratuito atualmente. A maioria dos fornecedores de Loyalty Programs for Independents oferece demonstracoes ou periodos de teste — solicite um de cada para avaliar antes de se comprometer.
O HT Score e um ranking composto que considera 4 grupos de criterios e mais de uma dezena de variaveis para ajudar hoteleiros a comparar objetivamente produtos de tecnologia hoteleira. etihad tem um HT Score de 0 e The Guestbook tem 100. Veja como a pontuacao e calculada.
| Grupo de Criterios | Peso | O Que Mede |
|---|---|---|
| Avaliacoes e Reviews de Clientes |
|
O quanto os usuarios recomendam este produto? Pontuacao de Avaliacoes, Volume de Reviews, Participacao de Mercado, Profundidade das Reviews, Recencia das Reviews, Casos de Sucesso ▾ O fator com maior peso. Analisa as avaliacoes medias de satisfacao (probabilidade de recomendar, facilidade de uso, suporte, ROI), contagem total de reviews em relacao aos pares da categoria, recencia das reviews (pelo menos 20 reviews nos ultimos 6 meses) e participacao de mercado entre clientes hoteleiros unicos para detectar vies de selecao. |
| Ecossistema de Parceiros |
|
O quanto os parceiros de tecnologia recomendam esta empresa? Recomendacoes de Parceiros, Quantidade de Integracoes, Qualidade das Integracoes ▾ Avalia recomendacoes de parceiros como votos de confianca de especialistas, o numero de integracoes verificadas e a qualidade do ecossistema — a media dos HT Scores dos parceiros de integracao. Produtos com ecossistemas de integracao de maior qualidade tem mais chances de entregar uma stack tecnologica conectada. |
| Foco no Cliente |
|
Qual o nivel de foco no cliente desta organizacao? Suporte Certificado, Consistencia de Reviews, Completude do Perfil ▾ Avalia se a empresa obteve a Certificacao de Suporte ao Cliente do HTR, mantem coleta consistente de reviews ao longo do tempo (um indicador de cultura orientada por feedback) e mantem perfis de produtos completos com capacidades, capturas de tela, precos e funcionalidades. |
| Alcance, Solidez e Recursos |
|
Qual a extensao do alcance e dos recursos desta empresa? Alcance Geografico, Solidez, Recursos da Empresa, Pontuacao de Tendencia ▾ Mede a presenca global (paises e regioes atendidos), anos de operacao como indicador de estabilidade, tamanho da equipe como indicador de recursos e uma pontuacao de tendencia baseada em consultas de compradores, reviews, recomendacoes de parceiros e atividade na imprensa dos ultimos doze meses. |
As avaliacoes e reviews de clientes sao, de longe, o fator mais importante no algoritmo do HT Score. O HTR nao aceita pagamento por rankings mais altos. Todas as reviews sao verificadas — apenas profissionais do setor hoteleiro com afiliacoes confirmadas podem enviar avaliacoes. Ver metodologia completa do HT Score →
Consultor de recomendações de produtos