The project dashboard is a free tool that is only available to verified hoteliers to make adopting new technology easier by streamlining their research and simplifying their communication workflow.
TLDR
Nous avons analyse 22 avis verifies d'hoteliers, compare les fonctionnalites, les tarifs et des etudes de cas reelles pour identifier les points forts de chaque plateforme. Le bon choix depend du type de votre etablissement et de vos priorites :
dormakaba se distingue en ease of use and customer support .
Mount Kelvin se distingue , avec des fonctionnalites exclusives comme Guest Comfort Controls.
Notes comparees basees sur 22 avis verifies d'hoteliers sur HTR.
| HTScore |
|
|
| Probabilite de recommandation |
|
|
| Facilite d'utilisation |
|
|
| Support client |
|
|
| Rapport qualite-prix |
|
|
| Prix de depart | Contact sales | Contact sales |
| Avis verifies | 22 | 0 |
Comment chaque produit se classe parmi les fournisseurs Système de gestion des chambres d'hôtes pour differentes tailles d'etablissements, types et regions — base sur les avis verifies d'hoteliers dans chaque segment.
Par taille d'hotel
| Segment |
dormakaba
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Petit (10-24 chambres) | #1 2 avis | — |
| Moyen (25-74 chambres) ▾ | #1 18 avis | — |
| Grand (75-199 chambres) | #2 1 avis | — |
| Tres grand (200+ chambres) | #2 1 avis | — |
Par type d'etablissement
| Segment |
dormakaba
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Boutique ▾ | #1 9 avis | — |
| Luxe ▾ | #1 7 avis | — |
| Enseigne / Chaine ▾ | #1 14 avis | — |
| Sejour prolonge ▾ | #1 5 avis | — |
Par region
| Segment |
dormakaba
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Amerique du Nord ▾ | #1 21 avis | — |
Choosing the right guest room management system is vital for your hotel's operational efficiency and guest satisfaction. Both Dormakaba RT Plus and Mount Kelvin aim to optimize your property’s room control, but they approach this goal differently. Dormakaba has a long-standing presence and a broad feature set, while Mount Kelvin offers innovative automation capabilities. Which system aligns best with your hotel’s needs and future plans?
Dormakaba RT Plus is an established player in the hotel industry, with over 21 reviews and a high customer support rating of 4.81/5. Its reputation is built on ease of use (4.52/5) and a solid value score of 4.47/5, indicating strong confidence from users. Conversely, Mount Kelvin has no recent reviews, no customer support ratings, and zero review count, making its data less reliable.
While Dormakaba provides a comprehensive guest room management system with 27 verified partners, Mount Kelvin's offerings are limited to five core features mainly focused on lighting and automation. This makes Dormakaba the safer choice for hotels that prioritize proven solutions backed by a large user base. Are you comfortable exploring a less-tested product with innovative features, or do you prefer a reliable, well-supported platform?
If your hotel needs a dependable, widely adopted system with extensive integrations and proven support, dormakaba RT Plus is your choice. Its large installed base and positive recent reviews suggest it can handle complex hotel environments effectively.
If your team is looking for a more modern automation platform emphasizing lighting controls, energy management, and future-proof digital integration, Mount Kelvin fits the bill—though its lack of reviews makes this a risk. For properties seeking a mature, supported solution, Dormakaba is more suitable. Conversely, if your hotel is open to experimenting with automation technology and values innovative features over proven track record, Mount Kelvin might be worth considering.
Dormakaba scores a high 4.52/5 in ease of use, with reviews praising its straightforward interface and clear communication during onboarding. Customers also report a smooth onboarding process rated at 4.63/5, which helps staff adopt the system quickly.
Mount Kelvin, however, has no available ratings, reviews, or user feedback, making it impossible to assess its usability. Given its focus on automation and controls, its user-friendliness remains untested in the market. For now, the edge goes to dormakaba as the more user-friendly, well-documented solution that your team can implement confidently.
Dormakaba offers a basic guest room management platform but does not specify unique features beyond core room access and management. Mount Kelvin, on the other hand, includes five features not found in dormakaba: master and entry lighting controls, guest comfort controls, occupancy-based thermostats, network optimization and analytics, and wireless door lock integrations.
If your hotel requires advanced automation, lighting, and energy-saving features, Mount Kelvin’s feature set offers more options. However, dormakaba’s broader integration network (27 verified partners) ensures compatibility with many existing systems, making it more versatile overall. The edge goes to Mount Kelvin for specialized automation, but dormakaba’s wider ecosystem support remains a significant advantage.
Dormakaba’s customer support is rated at 4.81/5, with reviews stating support staff are helpful and responsive. Customers highlight Germain Muhirwa’s patience and problem-solving skills as key strengths, though some wish for 24-hour support.
Mount Kelvin provides no support ratings or recent reviews, making it impossible to evaluate its support quality. Given the critical nature of support for system uptime and troubleshooting, dormakaba’s established reputation provides more confidence. For now, dormakaba holds the edge in support, especially for properties that require responsive assistance.
Dormakaba boasts 27 verified partners, including RoomRaccoon, Zaplox, WebRezPro, Nonius, Stayntouch, and Oracle Hospitality, among others. These integrations span property management, POS, and other systems, making dormakaba adaptable to diverse hotel setups.
Mount Kelvin has no verified integrations listed, limiting its ability to connect with other hotel systems. For properties that rely on a broad ecosystem of software, dormakaba’s extensive partner network is a clear advantage. The edge clearly favors dormakaba for integration capabilities.
Dormakaba’s reviews are recent, with a total of 21 and a high likelihood of recommendation at 91%. Ratings focus on ease of use, support, and value, reflecting satisfaction among various hotel segments, including luxury, branded, and limited-service hotels.
Mount Kelvin has no reviews, recent or otherwise, and no rating data. This lack of feedback makes it impossible to gauge user satisfaction or property-specific preferences. Based on available data, dormakaba is the preferred choice among hoteliers, especially given its proven track record and recent, positive feedback.
Pricing information for dormakaba RT Plus is not publicly available, indicating a customized quote model likely based on property size and needs. Mount Kelvin also does not publish pricing details, which suggests a tailored approach, possibly with variable costs depending on system complexity.
Both products operate on a quote-based model, so your team should expect to contact vendors for detailed proposals and pricing estimates tailored to your property’s size and requirements.
Not ideal if your hotel prefers experimenting with new automation platforms or requires a system with advanced lighting controls not integrated into dormakaba.
Not ideal if your hotel needs a proven, widely supported system with extensive third-party integrations or prefers comprehensive customer support.
In essence, dormakaba RT Plus is a mature, well-supported system favored by a large user base and backed by a broad ecosystem of integrations. Its ease of use, customer support, and recent reviews make it the safer choice for most hotels seeking reliability and proven performance.
Mount Kelvin offers innovative automation features that can enhance guest experience and energy efficiency but lacks recent reviews, support ratings, and a broad partner network. It is better suited for tech-savvy properties willing to accept higher risk for cutting-edge automation capabilities.
If your hotel values proven track records, extensive integrations, and strong support, dormakaba RT Plus stands out as the clear preferred choice. For hotels interested in automation and lighting controls and prepared for less market presence, Mount Kelvin could be worth a trial, but with caution.
La tarification des Système de gestion des chambres d'hôtes est rarement simple. Voici ce que nous savons a partir des donnees tarifaires publiques de chaque fournisseur. Demandez toujours un devis personnalise pour la taille de votre etablissement.
dormakaba
|
|
|---|
Selon la base de donnees produits de HTR, Dormakaba RT Plus et Mount Kelvin partagent 0 fonctionnalites. Voici les differences cles — les fonctionnalites que l'un possede et que l'autre n'a pas.
| Fonctionnalite |
dormakaba
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Commandes d'éclairage principal et d'entrée | ||
| Commandes de confort des clients | ||
| Intégrations de serrure de porte sans fil | ||
| Optimisation du réseau et analyse | ||
| Thermostats basés sur l'occupation |
Fonctionnalites uniques
Ou les notes divergent le plus
Cela depend de vos besoins. Dormakaba RT Plus et Mount Kelvin partagent de nombreuses fonctionnalites Guest Room Management System de base, mais chacun a des capacites uniques. Dormakaba RT Plus propose 27 partenaires d'integration verifies, tandis que Mount Kelvin en propose 0. Consultez la comparaison des fonctionnalites ci-dessus pour voir les differences avant de changer.
Les petits hotels devraient privilegier la facilite d'utilisation et une mise en service rapide. Dormakaba RT Plus est en tete pour la facilite d'utilisation avec 4.5/5 contre 0.0/5. Recherchez une tarification transparente et une option d'essai ou de demonstration. Filtrez les avis sur chaque page produit par taille d'etablissement pour lire les retours d'hotels similaires au votre.
Dormakaba RT Plus : Non. Mount Kelvin : Non. Aucun des deux produits ne propose actuellement d'offre gratuite. La plupart des fournisseurs Guest Room Management System proposent des demonstrations ou des essais — demandez-en un a chacun pour evaluer avant de vous engager.
Le HT Score est un classement composite qui prend en compte 4 groupes de criteres et plus d'une douzaine de variables pour aider les hoteliers a comparer objectivement les produits technologiques hoteliers. dormakaba a un HT Score de 0 et Mount Kelvin a 0. Voici comment le score est calcule.
| Groupe de criteres | Ponderation | Ce qu'il mesure |
|---|---|---|
| Notes et avis clients |
|
A quel point les utilisateurs recommandent-ils ce produit ? Score des notes, Volume d'avis, Part de voix, Profondeur des avis, Recence des avis, Etudes de cas ▾ Le facteur le plus fortement pondere. Analyse les notes de satisfaction moyennes (probabilite de recommandation, facilite d'utilisation, support, ROI), le nombre total d'avis par rapport aux pairs de la categorie, la recence des avis (au moins 20 avis sur les 6 derniers mois) et la part de voix parmi les clients hoteliers uniques pour detecter les biais de selection. |
| Ecosysteme partenaire |
|
A quel point les partenaires technologiques recommandent-ils cette entreprise ? Recommandations des partenaires, Nombre d'integrations, Qualite des integrations ▾ Evalue les recommandations des partenaires comme des votes de confiance d'experts, le nombre d'integrations verifiees et la qualite de l'ecosysteme — la moyenne des HT Scores des partenaires d'integration. Les produits avec des ecosystemes d'integration de meilleure qualite sont plus susceptibles de fournir un ensemble technologique connecte. |
| Orientation client |
|
A quel point cette organisation est-elle orientee client ? Support certifie, Regularite des avis, Completude du profil ▾ Evalue si l'entreprise a obtenu la certification HTR de support client, maintient une collecte d'avis reguliere dans le temps (un indicateur de culture axee sur le feedback) et tient a jour les profils produits avec les fonctionnalites, captures d'ecran, tarifs et caracteristiques. |
| Portee, perennite et ressources |
|
Quelle est l'etendue de la portee et des ressources de cette entreprise ? Portee geographique, Perennite, Ressources de l'entreprise, Score de tendance ▾ Mesure la presence mondiale (pays et regions desservis), les annees d'activite comme indicateur de stabilite, les effectifs comme indicateur de ressources, et un score de tendance base sur les demandes d'acheteurs, les avis, les recommandations de partenaires et l'activite presse des douze derniers mois. |
Les notes et avis clients sont de loin le facteur le plus important dans l'algorithme du HT Score. HTR n'accepte aucun paiement pour un meilleur classement. Tous les avis sont verifies — seuls les professionnels du secteur hotelier avec des affiliations confirmees peuvent soumettre des notes. Voir la methodologie complete du HT Score →
Recommandations personnalisées adaptées à votre propriété