HotelKey PMS vs. Prostay:
Which Is Right for You?

The Decision

Choosing a property management system (PMS) is pivotal for your hotel’s operational efficiency and guest experience. HotelKey PMS by HotelKey offers a comprehensive, well-established platform with numerous integrations, while Prostay by Prostay presents a newer, ultra-modern alternative with fewer integrations but compelling features. Your decision hinges on your hotel’s size, complexity, and preferred ecosystem. Which product aligns better with your current needs and future growth plans?

Is HotelKey or Prostay Better for Hotels?

Both HotelKey and Prostay aim to streamline hotel operations, but they approach this goal differently. HotelKey’s platform is trusted by over 1,250,000 rooms across 18,000+ hotels, emphasizing stability, extensive integrations, and a broad feature set. Prostay, still relatively new with five reviews, touts its intuitive interface, multi-property support, and offline capabilities but has a limited number of integrations. Do you prioritize proven stability and a broad feature library, or are you seeking simplicity and flexibility in a newer system?

HotelKey vs Prostay: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your hotel needs a robust, proven PMS with extensive integrations, HotelKey’s 31 verified partners and more than 30 shared features make it the obvious choice. Its high configurability suits mid-to-large properties, especially motels and budget hotels, where reliability and customization are critical. Conversely, if your hotel is a resort or boutique looking for an easy-to-learn, modern interface with strong automation and offline support, Prostay’s 2 verified integrations and focus on speed and simplicity might serve you better.

While HotelKey’s reputation is built on serving large chains and independent hotels with a focus on stability, Prostay’s appeal lies in its user-friendly design and innovative features like task management and rules-based room assignments. Your choice should reflect whether proven reliability or streamlined usability is your priority.

Is HotelKey or Prostay Easier to Use?

HotelKey scores 4.62/5 for ease of use, with many reviewers praising its quick onboarding, intuitive interface, and mobile app. Users mention that staff can be trained within hours, and real-time management is facilitated through mobile apps, especially for properties managing multiple locations.

Prostay slightly edges out with a 4.8/5 rating, emphasizing its straightforward workflows and modern design. Its well-thought-out features and native apps across platforms help staff adapt rapidly, especially for resorts with complex operations.

Edge: Prostay.

Which Has Better Features: HotelKey or Prostay?

HotelKey boasts 19 features exclusive to its platform, including online check-in, digital registration, guest messaging, and integrated ID & passport scanning—tools that enhance operational efficiency and guest experience. Its large feature library also covers shift planning, PCI compliance, and house mobile apps, offering a high level of customization.

Prostay offers only 7 unique features, but they are targeted at automation and guest engagement, such as native email marketing, task management, and rules-based room assignments. It also includes a proprietary POS and a guest/agent messaging platform, streamlining communication and operations.

While HotelKey’s feature count is significantly higher, Prostay’s targeted automation tools can be more impactful for properties that want quick workflows and guest engagement.

Edge: HotelKey.

Which Has Better Customer Support: HotelKey or Prostay?

HotelKey has a support rating of 4.38/5, with reviews highlighting helpful staff and quick issue resolution. However, some users mention inconsistent support experiences, noting delays and occasional unhelpfulness.

Prostay scores a perfect 5/5, with reviewers consistently praising its responsive, knowledgeable support team. Although it has fewer reviews, the recent ratings suggest a highly attentive customer service experience.

Edge: Prostay.

Which Has More Integrations: HotelKey or Prostay?

HotelKey offers 31 verified integrations, including key partners like Stripe, Revinate, and Nonius. These integrations facilitate payments, guest feedback, and channel management, making it suitable for hotels seeking a connected ecosystem.

Prostay has only 2 verified partners, with common integrations including STAAH and Stripe. While fewer in number, these integrations cover essential channels like payment and distribution but may limit expansion without additional connectors.

Edge: HotelKey.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: HotelKey or Prostay?

HotelKey’s overall rating is 4.96/5 based on 30 reviews, with many praise for its reliability and ease of onboarding. Notably, its hotelier base spans motels to boutique hotels, with a high likelihood (92%) of recommending the platform.

Prostay, with only 5 reviews and a 0/5 ratings in some segments, has a perfect score of 10/10 for likelihood to recommend, but the limited data makes it less conclusive. Hoteliers managing larger or more complex properties tend to favor HotelKey’s proven track record.

Edge: HotelKey.

How Much Do HotelKey and Prostay Cost?

HotelKey’s pricing is set at $800 per month with no free trial or tiered options, reflecting its enterprise-grade features and stability. Prostay offers a lower base price of $600 per month, also without a trial, making it a more affordable option for properties seeking modern features without the higher price tag.

Both systems do not list implementation fees or flexible monthly plans, so total costs depend on specific property needs and negotiations.

What Type of Hotel Should Use HotelKey?

• Hotels that operate at a larger scale, especially motels or budget properties, needing proven stability and extensive integrations.
• Teams managing multiple locations or properties with complex operational workflows.
• Hotels that want a customizable platform with integrated ID scanning, online check-in, and mobile housekeeping apps.
• Properties prioritizing a reliable, mature system with broad ecosystem connections.

Not ideal if your hotel is small, boutique, or prioritizes simplicity over extensive features, as the system’s complexity might be overwhelming.

What Type of Hotel Should Use Prostay?

• Resorts or boutique hotels looking for a user-friendly, fast-to-implement PMS with automation.
• Hotels that value mobile access, offline operation, and simple workflows.
• Properties seeking a modern interface focused on automation, guest communication, and task management.
• Hotels that want a cost-effective solution with native apps and multi-property support.

Not ideal if your hotel needs a vast array of integrations or sophisticated revenue management tools. Large chains requiring enterprise-level stability may find Prostay’s current ecosystem limited.

HotelKey vs Prostay: The Bottom Line for Hotels

HotelKey’s core strength lies in its extensive feature set, proven stability, and wide ecosystem of integrations, making it suitable for mid-to-large properties seeking reliability and customization. Its larger review base and recent feedback reinforce its position as a mature, trusted platform.

Prostay, although newer with fewer reviews, offers a fresh, intuitive interface optimized for resorts and boutique hotels that prioritize speed, automation, and offline capabilities. Its high customer support rating and modern design make it appealing to properties willing to trade some integration breadth for ease of use.

If your hotel requires a mature, extensively integrated PMS with proven reliability, HotelKey is the clear choice. For properties valuing simplicity, automation, and modern design at a lower cost, Prostay is worth considering.

In conclusion, go with HotelKey if your hotel needs a proven, highly customizable platform with broad integrations and enterprise features. Opt for Prostay if you want an easy-to-use, automation-focused system that supports multi-property operations and offline functionality. Your hotel’s specific operational scope and future growth plans should guide your final decision.