Comanche PMS vs. RoomRaccoon PMS:
Which Is Right for You?

The Decision

Choosing the right property management system (PMS) can determine how smoothly your hotel runs and how much revenue you generate. Both Comanche PMS and RoomRaccoon PMS aim to streamline operations, but their approaches and maturity differ significantly. Your decision hinges on your hotel’s size, complexity, and growth plans.

Comanche PMS offers a traditional, enterprise-level solution, but its lack of recent updates and reviews makes it a less reliable option today. RoomRaccoon, on the other hand, dominates the market with a high review count and recent positive feedback, making it the more trustworthy choice for most hoteliers.

Is Comanche PMS or RoomRaccoon PMS Better for Hotels?

Comanche PMS has been around since 2003, serving a broad range of properties, yet it currently holds a 0/5 star rating from HotelTechReport, with no recent reviews to support ongoing reliability. Conversely, RoomRaccoon boasts a 4.88/5 overall score based on 169 reviews, with five reviews in the last six months, indicating active customer satisfaction.

Both products aim to centralize operational control, but Comanche’s lack of recent updates raises questions about its current usability and support. RoomRaccoon’s modern, cloud-based platform provides frequent updates and a user interface praised for its ease. Are you willing to adopt a system with no recent customer feedback, or do you prefer a solution with a demonstrably active user base?

RoomRaccoon PMS vs Comanche PMS: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your hotel needs an all-in-one, easy-to-use platform that reduces manual work and automates communication, RoomRaccoon is the clear choice. Its strong focus on automation, integrated booking engine, channel management, and revenue tools suits small to medium-sized independent hotels and boutique properties.

If, however, your hotel is part of a large chain or requires complex, multi-property management with a tailored enterprise solution, Comanche might appear suitable — but its outdated reviews and zero recent data make this riskier. For most independent hotels and small chains, RoomRaccoon’s current functionality and support make it the recommended option.

Is Comanche PMS or RoomRaccoon PMS Easier to Use?

RoomRaccoon scores highly for usability, with a 4.74/5 rating and numerous reviews praising its intuitive interface, easy onboarding, and straightforward management process. Guests like that it’s “very simple to learn and teach” and appreciate the mobile app for managing bookings on the go.

Comanche’s usability is unverified due to a lack of recent reviews, and its overall rating of 0/5 suggests it might be obsolete or unsupported. The absence of recent feedback and a modern UI likely puts Comanche at a disadvantage. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Has Better Features: Comanche PMS or RoomRaccoon PMS?

RoomRaccoon offers an impressive 51 features, including a channel manager, revenue management, booking engine, integrated payments, guest CRM, automated upselling, and mobile app. It combines operational, marketing, and revenue features in one platform, simplifying hotel management.

In contrast, Comanche provides no documented features or recent updates, leaving its capabilities unknown. Given the extensive feature set of RoomRaccoon and its active development, it clearly leads. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Has Better Customer Support: Comanche PMS or RoomRaccoon PMS?

RoomRaccoon’s support team is rated 4.53/5, with reviews highlighting quick, helpful responses, and a focus on customer success. Hoteliers praise their responsiveness, especially during onboarding and troubleshooting.

Comanche’s support rating is unavailable, and the lack of recent reviews suggests support may be unresponsive or unsupported. Hotel staff need reliable assistance; RoomRaccoon’s active support and recent positive feedback make it the safer bet. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: Comanche PMS or RoomRaccoon PMS?

RoomRaccoon enjoys a 4.88/5 overall rating from 169 reviews, with recent feedback praising its ease of use, automation, and revenue features. Its reviews come from a variety of hotel segments, including boutique, city center, and serviced apartments.

Comanche’s rating is zero, with no verifiable recent reviews, indicating it’s unlikely to be actively used or supported. For current satisfaction, RoomRaccoon is far superior. Edge: RoomRaccoon.

How Much Do Comanche PMS and RoomRaccoon PMS Cost?

Comanche’s pricing is not publicly available, which suggests a custom or enterprise quote. RoomRaccoon charges a $1,000 monthly base fee, with no mention of additional per-room or implementation fees.

Given the transparency and manageable pricing model of RoomRaccoon, it offers clearer value assessment for small to medium hotels. Comanche’s unclear pricing makes budgeting difficult, and its lack of recent reviews raises concerns about ongoing costs or support.

What Type of Hotel Should Use Comanche PMS?

• Hotels that require a tailored, enterprise-level system and are comfortable with a legacy solution.
• Large resorts or multi-property chains with complex operational needs.
• Hotels that prioritize customization over user experience and frequent updates.
• Not ideal if your hotel seeks a modern, easy-to-adopt platform with active support.

Comanche might suit properties with extensive in-house IT resources seeking a specialized, customizable system, but it’s not recommended for most small to midsize hotels.

What Type of Hotel Should Use RoomRaccoon PMS?

• Independent hoteliers and boutique hotels looking for an all-in-one, straightforward management system.
• Small to medium-sized properties aiming to automate bookings, guest communication, and revenue management.
• Hotels wanting a cloud-based platform with frequent updates and active support.
• Not ideal if your property requires complex multi-property management or highly customizable enterprise features.

RoomRaccoon fits the needs of properties that value ease of use, automation, and rapid deployment, especially smaller operators seeking growth tools without complexity.

RoomRaccoon vs Comanche: The Bottom Line for Hotels

The core difference rests in their market approach and current relevance. RoomRaccoon provides an integrated, regularly updated platform with a large base of recent reviews, making it a reliable choice for most hoteliers today.

If your hotel values ease of use, automation, and ongoing support, RoomRaccoon’s extensive feature set and active customer feedback make it the clear winner. Comanche, with no recent activity or reviews, appears outdated and unsupported, and is unlikely to meet the needs of modern hotels.

Choose RoomRaccoon if you want a proven, user-friendly system that can grow with your hotel. Only consider Comanche if you have specific, enterprise-level requirements and are prepared for the risks of an unsupported legacy platform.

In summary, for most small to midsize hotels aiming to streamline operations and boost revenue, RoomRaccoon offers a better, more current solution. Its extensive reviews and recent customer satisfaction scores underscore its capacity to serve your hotel effectively now and in the future.