SiteMinder vs. Welcome Pickups vs. MyStay: Which is a Better Fit?

Compare SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling) vs Welcome Pickups vs MyStay

SiteMinder

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

131 reviews
Welcome Pickups

Welcome Pickups

118 reviews
MyStay

MyStay

45 reviews

Compare SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling) vs Welcome Pickups vs MyStay

Upselling Software vendor comparison between SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling) vs Welcome Pickups vs MyStay. Find out which Upselling Software is right for you based on realtime data from 294 verified hotelier reviews across 64 countries.

SiteMinder

SiteMinder

Ranked 4 (out of 65)

4.8
131 reviews
View profile
Welcome Pickups

Welcome Pickups

Ranked 8 (out of 65)

4.9
118 reviews
View profile
MyStay

MyStay

Ranked 11 (out of 65)

4.8
45 reviews
View profile

Ratings Summary

HT Score

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

83 HTScore Icon

Welcome Pickups

75 HTScore Icon

MyStay

19 HTScore Icon
Popularity

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

131 verified reviews

Welcome Pickups

118 verified reviews

MyStay

45 verified reviews
Likelihood to Recommend

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

95%

Welcome Pickups

98%

MyStay

96%
Ease of Use

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

4.8

Welcome Pickups

4.9

MyStay

4.9
ROI

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

4.6

Welcome Pickups

4.7

MyStay

4.8
Implementation

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

4.8

Welcome Pickups

4.8

MyStay

4.7
Customer Support

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

4.8

Verified Customer Support

Welcome Pickups

4.8

Verified Customer Support

MyStay

4.9

Verified Customer Support

Certificate of Excellence

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Welcome Pickups

MyStay

Features

Content Management

Deal/Offer Templates Library

Dynamic Upgrade Pricing

Automated A/B Testing

On property upsells

Future stay offers

Gift Vouchers

Customer Profiles

Segmentation

Guest Communication

Omnichannel (email, chat, sms, Whatsapp)

Check-in upselling

Pre-arrival emails

Upsell at booking

Fulfillment & Payments

Type 2 SOC 2 Certified (Data Security)

Fulfillment Task Automation (via Task Mgmt Integrations)

On property upsells

Check-in upselling

Gift Vouchers

Analytics/Reporting

Automated A/B Testing

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Content Management

Customer Profiles

Guest Communication

Fulfillment & Payments

Analytics/Reporting

Welcome Pickups

Content Management

Customer Profiles

Guest Communication

Fulfillment & Payments

Analytics/Reporting

MyStay

Content Management

Customer Profiles

Guest Communication

Fulfillment & Payments

Analytics/Reporting

GATHER BIDS FROM THESE 3-VENDORS IN 1-CLICK

TOP Matches

SiteMinder
vs.
Welcome Pickups
vs.
MyStay

Customers

Top 3 Segments

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

City Center Hotels - 20%
Boutiques - 20%
Resorts - 12%

Welcome Pickups

Boutiques - 25%
City Center Hotels - 21%
Bed & Breakfast & Inns - 10%

MyStay

Bed & Breakfast & Inns - 20%
Other - 16%
City Center Hotels - 13%
Featured clients

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

SiteMinder doesn’t have any featured brands available

-
-

Fit Score for Your Property

Want to find out which vendor is the best fit for your hotels?

Take the quiz

Pricing

Pricing Benchmark

Average

This product is priced in line with the average product in the category which is usually an indicator that it is a standard product with standard functionality designed for typical operations and use cases and properties.

SiteMinder Average SiteMinder

Average

This product is priced in line with the average product in the category which is usually an indicator that it is a standard product with standard functionality designed for typical operations and use cases and properties.

Welcome Pickups Average Welcome Pickups

Pricing Available By Request

MyStay has opted not to share general pricing on their profile but you can request a quote below. Often this is an indicator that pricing is flexible so it is recommended that you obtain multiple price quotes to negotiate.

How many rooms does your hotel have?

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Average
This product is priced in line with the average product in the category which is usually an indicator that it is a standard product with standard functionality designed for typical operations and use cases and properties.

Welcome Pickups

Average
This product is priced in line with the average product in the category which is usually an indicator that it is a standard product with standard functionality designed for typical operations and use cases and properties.

MyStay

Pricing Available By Request
MyStay has opted not to share general pricing on their profile but you can request a quote below. Often this is an indicator that pricing is flexible so it is recommended that you obtain multiple price quotes to negotiate.
Custom Price Quote
SiteMinder
vs.
Welcome Pickups
vs.
MyStay

What Customers Are Saying

Most Recent Review

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

The best ally for your hotel

Revenue manager from Cartagena (Colombia)

Welcome Pickups

The best and most professional transfer service we've partnered with.

Front Office / Concierge from Lisbon (Portugal)

MyStay

MyStay experience

Operation Manager
Most Positive Review

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Good emailing and announcements feature

Manager

Welcome Pickups

Reliable and efficient. Great service!

Front Desk Manager

MyStay

Perfect all in one solution

Owner from
Most Critical

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Great way to connect to your guests

Hotel manager

Welcome Pickups

Good Service, and easy to work with.

Front desk manager

MyStay

Easy check in

Managing director
References

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Kaidi Krimm
BusinesDevelopment Director Tallink Express Hotel

GuestJoy enables us to offer the services and products of our hotels with less effort. The GuestJoy app is easy to ...

-
-

General Info

Screenshots
Integrations

SiteMinder Guest Engagement (Upselling)

Property Management Systems (71) Booking Engine (34) Revenue Management Systems (32)

Welcome Pickups

Property Management Systems (9) Channel Managers (8) Booking Engine (6)

MyStay

Property Management Systems (16) Hotel Management Software (9) Booking Engine (6)
Recent Articles

Welcome Pickups

Welcome Pickups doesn’t have any recent articles

MyStay

MyStay doesn’t have any recent articles