LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) vs. MyStay Check in: Which Is Right for You?

Updated November 17, 2026  ·  72 verified reviews analyzed

TLDR

We analyzed 72 verified hotelier reviews, compared feature sets, pricing, and real-world case studies to break down where each platform delivers. The right choice depends on your property type and priorities:

LIKE MAGIC shines in b2b and corporate booking functionality — especially for extended-stay properties (5.0/5), with exclusive features like Hotel Website Check-in Portal and Payment & Authorizations.

MyStay shines in contactless check-in — especially for vacation rental properties (5.0/5), with exclusive features like Guest Segmentation & Targeting and Multi-Channel Delivery (Email, SMS, WhatsApp, Chat).

See the full breakdown below ↓

How Does LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) Compare to MyStay Check in?

Side-by-side ratings based on 72 verified hotelier reviews on HTR.

HTScore
71
20
Likelihood to Recommend
99%
98%
Ease of Use
4.9/5
4.9/5
Customer Support
4.8/5
4.9/5
Value for Money
4.9/5
4.9/5
Starting Price From $700/mo From $400/mo
Verified Reviews 29 43

What Are the Pros and Cons of LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) vs MyStay Check in?

After analyzing 72 verified reviews, LIKE MAGIC users most value its b2b and corporate booking functionality, all-in-one guest journey platform, integration savings and reduced complexity, while MyStay users highlight contactless check-in, guest experience, guest communication. Click any theme to see what reviewers say.

LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
Pros
+ B2B and corporate booking functionality ▾
+ Contactless Check-In ▾
+ All-in-one guest journey platform ▾
+ Guest Experience ▾
+ Integration savings and reduced complexity ▾
+ Guest Communication ▾
+ Operational overviews and staff efficiency ▾
+ Support and Continuous Improvement ▾
Cons
− Customization gaps and branding limitations ▾
− Customization Options ▾
− Self-service upgrades and room selection ▾
− Integration with PMS ▾
− System Speed and Performance ▾

LIKE MAGIC vs MyStay: Rankings by Hotel Segment

How each product ranks among Contactless Check-in vendors for different property sizes, types, and regions — based on verified reviews from hoteliers in each segment.

By Hotel Size

Segment LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
Small (10-24 rooms) ▾ #7 12 reviews #5 15 reviews
Mid-Size (25-74 rooms) ▾ #7 11 reviews #6 10 reviews
Large (75-199 rooms) ▾ #11 3 reviews #4 7 reviews
X-Large (200+ rooms) — #7 3 reviews

By Property Type

Segment LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
Boutique ▾ #9 8 reviews #5 12 reviews
Luxury ▾ #15 2 reviews #4 11 reviews
Branded / Chain ▾ #16 2 reviews #5 12 reviews
Extended Stay ▾ #5 12 reviews #7 9 reviews

By Region

Segment LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
North America #18 1 reviews #7 3 reviews
Europe ▾ #5 27 reviews #4 32 reviews
Asia Pacific — #5 2 reviews
Middle East — #4 2 reviews

Is LIKE MAGIC or MyStay Better for Hotels?

LIKE MAGIC and MyStay both address the need for contactless check-in solutions that reduce front desk queues and improve guest convenience. They diverge primarily in their operational scope and integration depth. LIKE MAGIC excels in automating a broad range of hotel operations beyond check-in, including housekeeping and payment processing, making it suited for properties aiming to streamline multiple workflows. MyStay focuses more on customizable guest communication, upselling, and deep PMS integration, fitting hotels that prioritize digital marketing and segmented guest engagement.

Both products replace manual check-in with mobile-first, GDPR-compliant processes that let guests check in remotely or on-site via QR codes or kiosks. This reduces staffing needs at arrival and accelerates guest throughput. However, LIKE MAGIC’s richer operational automation contrasts with MyStay’s emphasis on multi-channel guest communication and tailored upselling campaigns.

LIKE MAGIC vs MyStay: Which Should Your Hotel Choose?

If your hotel is a small to mid-sized property in Europe or Asia Pacific that wants to automate front desk, housekeeping, and payment workflows alongside contactless check-in, LIKE MAGIC is a strong fit. Its 29 reviews show 5/5 overall satisfaction, especially from extended stay, boutique, and city center hotels with lean teams. Its integration with digital key systems and emphasis on self-service fits properties seeking operational efficiency and guest autonomy.

If you operate a hotel with a diverse portfolio across Europe, North America, or emerging markets, and require robust PMS integration plus advanced guest segmentation, upselling, and multi-channel messaging, MyStay’s 43 reviews with a 4.9/5 rating indicate it suits these needs. It appeals to properties that leverage digital marketing and guest communication to boost ancillary revenue and personalize stays. However, MyStay’s rating data is stable but less recent, and some users note speed and customization limitations.

For very small vacation rentals or boutique hotels, review volume is limited for both, so conclusions should be cautious. Neither offers a free trial. Both products are best for hotels ready to invest upfront ($700 LIKE MAGIC, $400 MyStay) without per-room fees.

Is LIKE MAGIC or MyStay Easier to Use?

Both LIKE MAGIC and MyStay earn identical ease of use and onboarding scores of 4.9 and 4.8 respectively, across 29 and 43 reviews. Users praise LIKE MAGIC for its intuitive, browser-based platform that simplifies guest and staff workflows without requiring app downloads. MyStay is noted for a straightforward interface that allows quick setup and immediate operational impact.

Reviewers of LIKE MAGIC highlight how the platform makes self-check-in seamless for guests, which reduces front desk interactions, while MyStay users emphasize the ease of automating communications and upsell offers. Neither product shows significant friction in staff adoption or guest use, though some LIKE MAGIC users desire simpler backend navigation.

Edge: Even.

Which Has Better Features: LIKE MAGIC or MyStay?

LIKE MAGIC offers 13 unique hotel-specific features not found in MyStay, including device-agnostic hotel website check-in portals, document and passport scanning, ID verification, multi-lingual support, payment authorizations, deposit collection, and e-signature registration cards. These features automate critical pre-arrival and identity verification steps, saving staff time and enhancing GDPR compliance. Its pre-arrival upselling and upgrade options directly increase revenue opportunities.

MyStay provides 10 features absent in LIKE MAGIC, notably PMS integration, guest segmentation and targeting, multi-channel delivery (email, SMS, WhatsApp, chat), offer orchestration spanning booking to post-stay, and offer experimentation with A/B testing. These empower hotels to tailor communications and upsell campaigns dynamically, improving marketing precision and ancillary sales.

Both products share four core features related to contactless check-in and messaging, but LIKE MAGIC prioritizes operational automation and guest identity management, while MyStay focuses on marketing-driven guest engagement.

Edge: LIKE MAGIC.

Which Has Better Customer Support: LIKE MAGIC or MyStay?

Customer support and onboarding ratings are virtually identical: LIKE MAGIC scores 4.8 and 4.8, MyStay 4.9 and 4.8, over 29 and 43 reviews respectively. MyStay’s reviewers frequently praise the high level of cooperation and responsiveness, noting continuous updates and improvements based on user feedback. LIKE MAGIC users report generally good response times, though some note variability in support staff familiarity.

Both platforms provide onboarding that users find efficient, with MyStay noted for quick setup and LIKE MAGIC for streamlined staff training—one case study cites staff training reduced to 1.5 days. No consistent complaints suggest major support issues for either product.

Edge: Even.

Which Has More Integrations: LIKE MAGIC or MyStay?

MyStay leads with 30 verified partners, nearly triple LIKE MAGIC’s 11. Both share four key integrations with PMS and service providers such as 4SUITES, apaleo GmbH, Oracle Hospitality, and Mews. LIKE MAGIC’s unique integrations include SALTO Systems for digital keys, Adyen for payments, Triptease for conversion, and TrustYou for reputation management.

MyStay’s broader integration portfolio includes many PMS systems like Priority Software, RoomRaccoon, HOTELTIME, Preno, and WuBook, plus digital marketing platforms like Net Affinity and Bookassist. This extensive ecosystem supports MyStay’s strength in guest segmentation, upselling, and multi-channel communication.

Hotels needing deep PMS connectivity and marketing automation will benefit from MyStay’s integration breadth, while LIKE MAGIC’s integrations are more focused on operational core systems and access control.

Edge: MyStay.

Which Do Hoteliers Rate Higher: LIKE MAGIC or MyStay?

LIKE MAGIC holds a perfect 5/5 rating across 29 reviews, while MyStay has 4.9/5 from 43 reviews. Both have no reviews in the last six months, so current ratings may not fully reflect recent product changes. Likelihood to recommend is 99% for LIKE MAGIC versus 98% for MyStay.

Segment breakdown shows LIKE MAGIC’s highest ratings are from extended stay and serviced apartments (5/5 from 12 reviews), limited service hotels (4.9/5 from 5), and boutique hotels (4.8/5 from 8). MyStay scores highest in vacation rentals (5/5 from 5), luxury hotels (4.9/5 from 11), and resorts (4.9/5 from 9). City center hotels and branded properties rate both similarly in the high 4.8–4.9 range.

Review volume favors MyStay, but LIKE MAGIC’s perfect ratings with fewer reviews indicate stronger satisfaction in its core segments. Both products are highly rated.

Edge: Even.

How Much Do LIKE MAGIC and MyStay Cost?

LIKE MAGIC charges a one-time base price of $700, with no freemium, monthly flat, or per-room fees. Implementation fees and trial offers are not disclosed.

MyStay’s base price is $400, similarly without freemium or monthly fees, and no trial offered.

Pricing is non-subscription and upfront, which suits hotels seeking to avoid ongoing per-room charges. MyStay is less expensive initially but offers fewer operational automation features. Neither vendor publishes additional pricing tiers or add-ons publicly.

What Type of Hotel Should Use LIKE MAGIC?

  • Hotels with small to mid-sized portfolios in Europe or Asia Pacific aiming to reduce front desk staffing and automate operations.
  • Extended stay and serviced apartments seeking integrated guest management, housekeeping coordination, and payment automation.
  • Properties prioritizing guest autonomy via mobile check-in, digital keys, and pre-arrival upselling.
  • Hotels requiring GDPR-compliant ID verification, passport scanning, and document signing.
  • Teams wanting a device-agnostic platform that requires minimal guest app downloads and supports multilingual guests.

Not ideal if:

  • Your property depends heavily on PMS-driven guest segmentation and multi-channel upsell marketing.
  • You operate outside LIKE MAGIC’s main regions (Europe, Asia Pacific) or need extensive PMS integrations.
  • You require customizable automated messaging templates or A/B testing for offers.

What Type of Hotel Should Use MyStay?

  • Hotels across Europe, North America, Middle East, and emerging markets needing contactless check-in with deep PMS integration.
  • Properties focused on maximizing ancillary revenue through sophisticated guest segmentation and targeted upselling.
  • Hotels wanting multi-channel guest communication via email, SMS, WhatsApp, and chat to engage guests pre- and post-arrival.
  • Teams that rely on digital acceptance, payment capture, and offer experimentation to optimize marketing campaigns.
  • Properties requiring a simple onboarding process and frequent software updates based on guest feedback.

Not ideal if:

  • You need advanced operational automation like housekeeping and payment processing integrated into the check-in workflow.
  • Your staff prefers a more streamlined backend interface and less complex feature set.
  • Your hotel portfolio is limited to Europe or Asia Pacific and prioritizes digital key integration and mobile-first guest access.

LIKE MAGIC vs MyStay: The Bottom Line for Hotels

LIKE MAGIC and MyStay both deliver strong contactless check-in solutions that improve guest experience and reduce front desk load. LIKE MAGIC distinguishes itself with richer operational automation, device-agnostic guest access, and advanced identity verification, fitting hotels aiming to streamline check-in, housekeeping, and payment in one platform. MyStay stands out for its extensive PMS integrations, guest segmentation, and multi-channel upselling, ideal for hotels prioritizing marketing-driven revenue growth and personalized guest communications.

Choose LIKE MAGIC if your hotel values operational efficiency and seamless self-service from arrival to late check-out, with features like digital key integration and document scanning that save staff time and improve compliance. It is particularly effective for extended stay, boutique, and city center hotels in Europe and Asia Pacific.

Choose MyStay if your hotel operates across multiple continents, requires broad PMS connectivity, and wants to leverage guest data for targeted upselling via multiple communication channels. Its strengths lie in boosting ancillary revenue and automating guest engagement workflows, appealing to luxury, resort, and branded properties.

The decision hinges on whether your priority is comprehensive operational automation (LIKE MAGIC) or sophisticated guest marketing and communication (MyStay). Both have strong, recent user satisfaction and no major weaknesses in support or usability.

How Much Do LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) and MyStay Check in Cost?

Contactless Check-in pricing is rarely straightforward. Here is what we know from each vendor's public pricing data. Always request a custom quote for your property size.

LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
Starting Price From $700/mo From $400/mo

Feature Comparison: LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) vs MyStay Check in

These are the features each vendor has configured, organized by feature group — the same data shown in the vendor dashboard. Expand a group to compare features side by side.

Feature LIKE MAGIC LIKE MAGIC MyStay MyStay
▾ Pre-Arrival & Check-in
84%
50%
Hotel Website Check-in Portal
Lobby Kiosk
Self Service Checkout
Self Service Checkin
Device Agnostic
Easy Room Selection
▾ Information Collection
100%
0%
Custom Questions
Terms & Conditions Signing
Marketing Communications Opt-in
Pre-regisration info collection
Document & Passport Scanning
ID Verification
▾ Translations
50%
0%
Automatic Translations
Multi-lingual
▾ Payments & Authorization
80%
0%
Registration Card E-signature
Collect Deposits
Payment & Authorizations
ID Verification
PCI Compliant
▾ Mobile Key
100%
100%
Door Lock Integration
▾ Upgrades & Upselling
50%
0%
Pre-arrival Upselling & Upgrades
Easy Room Selection
▾ Other
0%
100%
PMS Integration

Real-World Results: LIKE MAGIC vs MyStay by Business Goal

We analyzed 4 verified case studies to compare what hotels actually achieve with each platform across four key business objectives.

Increase Operational Efficiency
LIKE MAGIC The Zipper Hotel & Apartments Small
+ 80% fewer staff while maintaining operational efficiency
+ 4.6/5 rating on Google, 8.8+ on Booking.com
+ Easy to understand and use - employees have fun to work with. Fully trained staff in just 1.5 days.

"Like Magic allowed us to operate with just six staff members, without compromising guest experience. The platform is easy to use, fun to work with, and has revolutionized how we ru..."

MyStay MyStay

No published case study for this goal yet.

Improve Guest Experience
LIKE MAGIC Stay Kooook Small
+ Lean operations: Reduced staffing needs to 2.5 FTE for an 85-room property
+ Guest Journey adoption: Enabled 95% of guests to manage their entire stay digitally.
+ Decreased staff training time to under four hours for new employees.

"LIKE MAGIC isn't just a tool for us, it's the backbone of our overall guest experience. If I ever worked somewhere else, I'd bring it with me."

Cedric Maderer
Cedric Maderer
Product Manager
MyStay MyStay

No published case study for this goal yet.

LIKE MAGIC vs MyStay: The Bottom Line

LIKE MAGIC
LIKE MAGIC
5.0/5 from 29 reviews

What hoteliers love

B2B and corporate booking functionality 100% positive

One review notes that LikeMagic is tailored toward B2B use cases such as corporate clients, TMCs, and partners. This suggests the product is especiall... One review notes that LikeMagic is tailored toward B2B use cases such as corporate clients, TMCs, and partners. This suggests the product is especially useful for hotels that need structured booking workflows beyond standard leisure guest needs.

All-in-one guest journey platform 100% positive

Reviewers consistently describe LikeMagic as a single platform that combines online check-in, guest portal, and IBE into one flow. This reduces the ne... Reviewers consistently describe LikeMagic as a single platform that combines online check-in, guest portal, and IBE into one flow. This reduces the need for multiple tools and creates a smoother, more unified pre-arrival and in-stay guest experience.

Integration savings and reduced complexity 100% positive

The reviews highlight that LikeMagic reduces the need for third-party interfaces and saves significant time through integrations. Hotels value the low... The reviews highlight that LikeMagic reduces the need for third-party interfaces and saves significant time through integrations. Hotels value the lower operational complexity, fewer moving parts, and the ability to focus staff time on higher-value guest service.

Where hoteliers push back

Customization gaps and branding limitations 100% negative

A key negative theme is the lack of flexibility in branding and guest-facing customization. One reviewer says custom branding for the back office was... A key negative theme is the lack of flexibility in branding and guest-facing customization. One reviewer says custom branding for the back office was removed after being promised, and also wants more UX customization for the guest portal.

Self-service upgrades and room selection 100% negative

Reviewers want LikeMagic to support self-service room upgrades so guests can buy higher room categories during the digital journey. This is seen as an... Reviewers want LikeMagic to support self-service room upgrades so guests can buy higher room categories during the digital journey. This is seen as an opportunity to improve personalization and add incremental revenue, but it is currently missing.

Ranks higher for

City Center Hotels #4 vs #6
Extended Stay #5 vs #7
Hostels #9 vs #15
DE #3 vs #5

Unique capabilities

Hotel Website Check-in Portal Device Agnostic Custom Questions Terms & Conditions Signing Marketing Communications Opt-in
4.9/5 ease of use 4.8/5 support 11 integrations
Visit Profile
MyStay
MyStay
4.9/5 from 43 reviews

What hoteliers love

Contactless Check-In 100% positive

Reviewers frequently mention MyStay's contactless check-in feature as a crucial tool, especially during the pandemic. It simplifies and accelerates th... Reviewers frequently mention MyStay's contactless check-in feature as a crucial tool, especially during the pandemic. It simplifies and accelerates the check-in process, allowing guests to complete it before arrival, and reducing physical contact. Users appreciate the ease of use and efficiency it brings to their operation.

Guest Experience 84% positive

Reviewers often remarked how MyStay significantly enhances the guest experience. The platform allows for pre-arrival communications and on-arrival con... Reviewers often remarked how MyStay significantly enhances the guest experience. The platform allows for pre-arrival communications and on-arrival convenience, imparting a feeling of personalized and attentive service. Hoteliers noticed higher guest satisfaction as a direct outcome.

Guest Communication 97% positive

Many reviews highlight how MyStay improves guest communication. The platform allows hoteliers to efficiently communicate with guests before, during, a... Many reviews highlight how MyStay improves guest communication. The platform allows hoteliers to efficiently communicate with guests before, during, and after their stay through automated messages. This feature enhances guest satisfaction by providing timely information and resolving queries promptly.

Where hoteliers push back

Customization Options 55% negative

Users frequently suggested the need for more customization options, particularly in automated messaging and guest communication templates. They desire... Users frequently suggested the need for more customization options, particularly in automated messaging and guest communication templates. They desire more flexibility in adjusting texts, graphics, and automatic messaging formats to better suit their specific needs.

Integration with PMS 43% negative

MyStay's integration with property management systems (PMS) is a valuable feature, mentioned positively in several reviews. This seamless integration... MyStay's integration with property management systems (PMS) is a valuable feature, mentioned positively in several reviews. This seamless integration helps hoteliers manage guest data and operations more effectively. However, some users did encounter occasional syncing issues between MyStay and their PMS.

Ranks higher for

Large (75-199 rooms) #4 vs #11
Small (10-24 rooms) #5 vs #7
X-Small (< 10 rooms) #5 vs #10
Bed & Breakfast & Inns #5 vs #11

Unique capabilities

PMS Integration Guest Segmentation & Targeting Room Upgrade Merchandising Multi-Channel Delivery (Email, SMS, WhatsApp, Chat) Ancillary Product Merchandising
4.9/5 ease of use 4.9/5 support 30 integrations
Visit Profile

Frequently Asked Questions About LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) vs MyStay Check in

Can LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) replace MyStay Check in?

It depends on your requirements. LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) and MyStay Check in share many core Contactless Check-in features, but each has unique capabilities. LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) offers 11 verified integration partners, while MyStay Check in offers 30. Review the feature comparison above to see where they differ before switching.

Which is better for small or independent hotels?

Small hotels should prioritize ease of use and fast onboarding. LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) leads in ease of use at 4.9/5 vs 4.9/5. Look for transparent pricing and a trial or demo option. Filter reviews on each product page by property size to hear from hotels like yours.

Do LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) or MyStay Check in offer a free plan?

LIKE MAGIC (Check-in): No. MyStay Check in: No. Neither product currently offers a free tier. Most Contactless Check-in vendors offer demos or trials — request one from each to evaluate before committing.

How Does HTR Evaluate and Rank LIKE MAGIC (Check-in) and MyStay Check in?

The HT Score is a composite ranking that considers 4 criteria groups and over a dozen variables to help hoteliers objectively compare hotel technology products. LIKE MAGIC has an HT Score of 71 and MyStay has 20. Here is how the score is calculated.

Criteria Group Weight What It Measures
Customer Ratings & Reviews

How highly do users recommend this product?

Ratings Score, Review Volume, Share of Voice, Review Depth, Review Recency, Success Stories ▾

The most heavily weighted factor. Analyzes average satisfaction ratings (likelihood to recommend, ease of use, support, ROI), total review count relative to category peers, review recency (at least 20 reviews in the trailing 6 months), and share of voice across unique hotel clients to detect selection bias.

Partner Ecosystem

How highly do tech partners recommend this company?

Partner Recommendations, Integration Quantity, Integration Quality ▾

Evaluates partner recommendations as expert votes of confidence, the number of verified integrations, and ecosystem quality — the average HT Scores of integration partners. Products with higher-quality integration ecosystems are more likely to deliver a connected tech stack.

Customer Centricity

How customer-centric is this organization?

Certified Support, Review Consistency, Profile Completeness ▾

Assesses whether the company has earned HTR Customer Support Certification, maintains consistent review collection over time (an indicator of feedback-driven culture), and keeps product profiles complete with capabilities, screenshots, pricing, and features.

Reach, Staying Power & Resources

How extensive is this company's reach and resourcing?

Geographic Reach, Staying Power, Company Resources, Trending Score ▾

Measures global presence (countries and regions served), years in business as a stability proxy, team headcount as a resource proxy, and a trending score based on trailing-twelve-month buyer inquiries, reviews, partner recommendations, and press activity.

Customer ratings and reviews are by far the most important factor in the HT Score algorithm. HTR does not accept payment for higher rankings. All reviews are verified — only hotel industry practitioners with confirmed affiliations can submit ratings. View full HT Score methodology →

Get Your Free AI Analyst Report

Custom recommendations tailored to your property

Ghostel icon
Trusted by
footer image 1 footer image 2 footer image 3 footer image 4 footer image 5 footer image 6 footer image 7

Let´s lookup your hotel information